A blog on issues affecting Australia's newsagents, media and small business generally. More ...

Newsagency sales benchmark study results: 2022 vs. 2019

Thank you to the 119 newsagents trading under a variety of shingles and in a variety of settings (rural, regional and suburban high street) who provided sales data for this benchmark study. The only connection is that they use newsagency software from my POS software company. Their transparency will help many in our channel.

Plenty of good news in retail newsagency benchmark study comparing 2022 to 2019.

Many newsagents had an excellent 2022 compared to 2019, the majority who participated in this benchmark study in fact.

Common among those who did well is active engagement in non newsagency traditional product lines, active promotion of the business outside the business, and focussing on three key metrics: basket value, margin and the cost base of the business.

Common among the businesses that did not report as good results is their focus on traditional newsagency operation: lotteries, papers and magazines more so than other product categories.

What is particularly interesting is the results for businesses that transitioned from traditional in 2019 to innovate in 2022. In those cases, the results are extraordinary. In one million dollar business the revenue was almost the same but business GP% moves from 29% to 34%, which is an extra $50,000 in gross profit. In another business they added $120,000 to their $590,000 revenue with the added revenue for items achieving more than 50% GP.

This is the story that stands out when comparing 2022 to 2019, transition. Transition from relying on agency revenue, from relying on commission, to relying of good margin from sought-after products through which the business can attract new shoppers, non newsagency traditional shoppers. A highlight of the transition as evidenced in the dataset is that size and location do not matter. Okay, location in terms of shopping centre matters as it’s not proving to be a winner for our channel, but outside of shopping centres – city or country, large or small – success is equally attainable.

After comparing data from the businesses in the benchmark dataset here are the averages for business performance measurement points and categories, comparing 2022 with 2019:

  • Revenue: Up 9.5%.
  • Sales transaction count: Down 1%.
  • Basket value: Up 9%.
  • Items per basket: Up 7%.
  • Average item value: Up 7%.
  • Greeting card revenue: Up 7%.
  • Magazines unit sales: Down 1%. This is an unfair measure because of the big difference between businesses, bigger than for any other category.
  • Toy (incl. plush) revenue: Up 22%. 25% of those in the study have this category
  • Gift revenue: Up 35%.
  • Book revenue: Up 15%. 12% of those in the study have this category.
  • Fashion: 70%. 20% of those in the study have this category.
  • Stationery revenue: Up 3%.

Since the above results are averages, there are some considerably below and some considerably above.

There is also interesting data within departments, like stationery and magazines:

  • In magazines, weeklies experienced the biggest decline again. Special interest titles are the winners, often delivering double-digit growth.
  • In stationery, everyday is patchy but special interest, fringe, stationery is doing very well.
  • Newsagents with a unique add-on category, such as firearms, music or pet food, tend to see these doing well.

I have a note about traditional categories: lotteries, papers and magazines. They are important, but they should no longer define your business. Make what you can from them, support them well, but do 9other things to attract new shoppers who will purchase better margin products from you. And on magazines, if you focus on special interest titles and promote them outside your shop, you could do very well.

Evidence.

Common feedback I get from these benchmark studies is can I see the report for the best shop so I can learn. I can’t do that. But I can share snippets. Here are some category specific snippets from different businesses. The results speak for themselves.

Cards.

Gifts.

Toys.

Clothing.

Magazines.

I am concerned about my numbers, what can I do?

If you want better results it is up to you to act.

There is no one size fits all solution, anyone who says there is is wrong.

The first step is to understand where you are at, from the data evidence in your business. next, you need a plan. Then, you execute with clarity and commitment, and draw on the support of others who have done this.

I own newsXpress, a marketing group supporting newsagents. newsXpress helps with this. If it interests you, please email help@newsxpress.com.au or call Michael Elvey on 0400 331 055 – he’s not a sales person, he’s part of the team encouraging success.

Mark Fletcher
M | 0418 321 338
https://www.linkedin.com/in/mark-fletcher-tower/

17 likes
Newsagency benchmark

News Corp announces newspaper cover price increase

News Corp emailed newsagents yesterday about cover price increases.

Dear Newsagent/Distributor,

Effective Monday 27 February 2023, the Monday to Friday cover price of the following publications will increase by 30 cents to $2.80.

  • Herald Sun
  • The Daily Telegraph
  • The Courier-Mail
  • The Advertiser
  • The Mercury
  • NT News
  • Geelong Advertiser
  • Gold Coast Bulletin
  • Townsville Bulletin
  • Cairns Post
  • The Chronicle
  • Sunshine Coast Daily
  • Mackay Daily Mercury

An updated list of all relevant News Corp Australia publication cover prices, retail commissions, prices to retailers, distribution fees (where relevant) and prices to account is provided below.

We ask that you notify customers of the price change and ensure your systems are updated on the effective dates to reflect these changes.

As retail commission increases, so too will your total home delivery remuneration. We will provide the full detail of this change in a separate letter.

We thank you for your continued support and look forward to continuing to partner with you in driving new sales opportunities.

Should you wish to discuss this with us, please feel free to contact our News Retail Support Team.

It amazes me that, especially in Melbourne and Sydney given the products in those cities, people willingly pay to be told what to think.

7 likes
Newspapers

News Corp results

Mediaweek has reported on the latest News Corp results. Here’s part that relevant to what we sell:

News Media

Revenues in the quarter decreased $59 million, or 9%, as compared to the prior year, driven by a $65 million, or 10%, negative impact from foreign currency fluctuations and lower advertising revenues in constant currency, partially offset by higher circulation and subscription revenues in constant currency.

Within the segment, revenues at News Corp Australia and News UK decreased 13% and 10%, respectively, as both were impacted by negative foreign currency fluctuations. On a constant currency basis, revenues at News Corp Australia and News UK decreased 3% and increased 3%, respectively. Adjusted Revenues for the segment increased 1% compared to the prior year.

Circulation and subscription revenues decreased $20 million, or 7%, compared to the prior year, primarily due to a $31 million, or 11%, negative impact from foreign currency fluctuations and lower print volume. The decline was partially offset by cover price increases and digital subscriber growth.

Digital revenues represented 37% of News Media segment revenues in the quarter, compared to 34% in the prior year, and represented 35% of the combined revenues of the newspaper mastheads. Digital subscribers and users across key properties within the News Media segment are summarized below:

• Closing digital subscribers at News Corp Australia as of December 31, 2022 were 1,011,000 (924,000 for news mastheads), compared to 909,000 (861,000 for news mastheads) in the prior year (Source: Internal data).

Click here to access the company release.

2 likes
Newspapers

Try this different approach to assessing the performance of products in your shop

Knowing for certain the performance of inventory in your business will support better decision making. Too many decisions in local indie retail, however, are not made based on evidence.

The very simple approach I outline in this post could be done by anyone, and it could lead to profitable changes in your business.

With retail space usually costing between 11% and 15% of (non agency) revenue, it is usually the next highest cost outside of the cost of stock itself.

Retailers often argue that rent should be lower. It could be that a different view of shop floor performance helps you achieve a better return.

  • Take a blank sheet of paper, ideally A3, and roughly sketch out the layout of your shop, marking in display units, shelving, the counter – everywhere you have product. Include your back room if you have stock there.
  • Colour-shade the layout by department.
  • List the departments on the side of the floor plan.
  • Calculate the percentage of total space used for each department. This does not need to be accurate to two decimal places. List this next to each department you have listed.
  • Use your POS software to report on gross profit dollars earned by each department over the last year, or calculate it from sales figures knowing the average GP% per department.
  • Calculate the percentage of total gross profit contribution earned by each department and list this next to the floor space allocated to each department – on the floor plan map you have done.
  • Circle in green those performing the best, where the GP% contribution is more than the GP% space allocation, and in red those performing the worst.

The goal is to show you the performance by space, so you can work out if you should give more space to a category or less. Many shops don’t make changes to their shop floor by moving categories or increasing or decreasing space allocation. The evidence revealed by this quick GP analysis could lead to valuable changes.

Typically, a business owner doing this for the first time will have an ah ha moment, seeing something they had not realised.

I have seen business owners make changes including to floor layout, quitting suppliers and increasing stock weight for some departments.

You can take the analysis a step further by looking only at one department and analysing performance by category, using the method outlined above.

What I have outlined here is very basic, easy to do. It’s not something you need an accountant to advise you on. There is no downside is spending the new minutes it takes to do. So, do it!

12 likes
Newsagency management

Is there any interest in coronation memorabilia in Australia

I don’t think it will sell that well, people don’t like him.

And with that, the group of four retailers moved on from this stand offering coronation memorabilia at the Spring Fair in Birmingham yesterday.

There were several stands with products. The displays did not appear to attract people from what I could see as I walked past.

In the group of four I overheard there were 2 girls and 2 guys. The age range of this group I eavesdropped on was from 20s to 60s. They all agreed as to popularity, or not as it was in this case.

I’m aware of a couple of Australian importers pitching coronation memorabilia. It will be fascinating to see the interest in Australia.

I think there is a big difference between the pitch cushions, mugs and similar and commemorative mint coin sets. I suspect 2023 will offer us some good opportunities with the latter.

I didn’t come to Spring Fair to look for or consider coronation related products. On first glance I was surprised to see them, but it makes sense here in the UK.

2 likes
Newsagency management

Opportunities abound at Nuremburg Toy Fair

Spielwarenmesse, the international toy fair in Nuremberg/Germany, the world’s biggest toy fair was wonderful this year. I am grateful to have been able to be there, to see this 2023 event first-hand.

I met with plenty of Aussie suppliers who were there as well as some people from businesses not currently in Australia. Some were visiting while others were in the stands of their suppliers.

The sheer size of this event is extraordinary – way bigger than any trade show in Australia. Think the big Melbourne gift fair and multiply that by 10 or more. Yes, it is that big.

But size is not everything. It’s the innovation on show that I loved.

It is interesting seeing toy retailers from the US who I met at the New York toy fair now making the trip to Nuremburg. It makes sense as it is the first big toy show of the 2023 year.

Product launches in Nuremburg will not hit Australia in many cases until late in 2023. having an advance insight into this is wonderful, useful. Early insights  into the trends toy designers and makers see as important help too.

A couple of the trend highlights that interested me were the integration of tech, AI specifically as well as mobility products.

Getting around the event was extraordinary. In a day, 25,000 steps is nothing at this event. But in some halls, there were displays of delight and nostalgia. As is always the case at this trade show, the model train displays are a hit.

I appreciate not everyone can get to trade shows like Spielwarenmesse. I am here for newsXpress of course, to meet suppliers to the group, find new suppliers and to collect and share insights with group members. The trip has commercial value.

Thanks to better flight prices between Australia and Europe compared to flying two the US, it is economically valuable to be here, especially since in a week it can be a two trade show trip. But more on that another time.

That so many Australian suppliers are here speaks to the importance of this show in Nuremburg to their business back home in Australia.

9 likes
Newsagency opportunities

Smart buying: Having products that sell for more than one reason, to more than one type of shopper

The more we stock our shops that appeal to multiple buying situations the better for our retail businesses, the more efficient our inventory investment, the more opportunities for out of store promotions.

This candle is a good example of what I am talking about.

Candles are candles, right?! They are everywhere. Many different types of shops have them. The marketplace is covered well for people shopping by scent and different types of ingredients. And, new local makers are popping up almost daily.

This candle, by virtue of the fun text on the label, offers a different reason for purchase. It’s fun, self-deprecating, a good conversation opportunity when given.

Having items that could be purchased for more than on reason helps improve inventory efficiency in the business. In local small business retail this is especially important. If an additional reason is humorous related, it’s a bonus.

A candle like this in a town with plenty of candy outlets gives you differentiation.

This candle is an example. There are plenty of products you can buy to serve this purpose. My suggestion is to look for multiple purchase opportunity products, to expand the appeal of what you sell, and to provide you with opportunities to reach more possible shoppers through out of store marketing.

6 likes
Newsagency management

Why big retailers have ramped up their loyalty pitch in 2023 and what local newsagents can do about this

The major supermarkets, several other retailers and non-retail businesses are spending big pitching their loyalty programs already this year.

Their pitches tend to cast their loyalty program as key to unlocking value for shoppers. Value in this context should read as lower prices. It’s a big business code word. Value is bandied about in meetings as if they are doing something good for shoppers when, in fact, it’s marketing fluff to get people thinking they are saving money.

I think their increased focus on loyalty is their response to inflation and consumer sentiment associated with this.

Shoppers are concerned about prices, especially in must-purchase settings. From data we see, with want purchases, discretionary purchases, price is less of a concern.

I have found the best way to pitch value, real and genuine value, is through an easily understood loyalty program that does not compare to the poor-value over-hyped programs from the supermarkets and similar.

Seriously, what is a loyalty point worth anyway?

At my software com pay, Tower Systems, the specialty retail POS software / newsagency software has a good loyalty points facility in it, it’s the discount voucher loyalty program that many hundreds of my own retail customers prefer. I use it in my own shops and have done consistently since it was released 9 years ago.

Each voucher has a dollar value. People understand $$ more than %.

On average, 19% of vouchers are returned and of those returned, a third are redeemed the day of, a third within 7 days and the last third within 28 days.

Guys are more likely to redeem right away whereas girls are more likely to redeem a week or more later.

Discount vouchers work particularly well with habit-focussed shoppers.

In settings where shoppers don’t want the vouchers, there is an opportunity for a local charity connection, which extends the reach of the discount vouchers, better connects the business to a local charity and helps leverage that charity’s community to support you.

My advice, if you’re interested, is to take note that the major retailers are pitching loyalty more this year already. Consider what you can do in your business to engage with shopper interest in value.

Now for a sales pitch:

Find out more:

Thanks for reading.

Tower serves 3,000+ local specialty retailers across a range of product channels and are grateful to serve beyond our POS software, with retail advice and inspiration – to help local small business retailers compete and enjoy their businesses more. This is where local value can be nurtured and shared.

8 likes
Newsagency management

The Currency: Why the relationship between the newsagent and newspapers is no longer working

This article (behind a paywall) by The Currency is fascinating. 12.5% GP for a product achieving declining sales and with a high business carrying cost is weighing on the minds of plenty of retailers.

I wonder how many in publishing companies in Australia wonder about this.

The fear in the newspaper industry is that the retail model will eventually break down, and they will run out of retailers even before they run out of print readers.

Based on dumb decisions by senior managers in newspaper publishing companies that have hurt retailers in recent years, I guess not many.

Newspaper publishers need to make it appealing to stock their product. They demonstrate little understanding of this. Their approach continues to be rooted history, when having newspapers actually mattered to the future of a ‘newsagency’, when those men, yes it was pretty much always men, representing newsagents approached newspaper publishers tugging their forelock.

11 likes
Newspapers

Covid bloat in the supply chain

We continue to see Covid related bloat in parts of the supply chain, especially where products are sourced from China and have been unable to easily ship over the last 2 years.

From what I have seen, it appears most common with lower end gift and homewares products, from lesser known suppliers.

I think it’s important to be aware when considering product purchases – to ensure you’re looking at current design rather than products from two years ago.

2 likes
Newsagency management

ALNA lobbies on the paper shortage

MichaelWestMedia published this AAP story outlining ALNAs involvement lobbying on the paper shortage situation.

Paper shortage pressures school stationery

by  | January 19, 2023 13:27 | News

Parents shopping for back-to-school stationery could face price hikes and empty shelves, as logistics and materials pressures cause suppliers to ration goods.

The Australian Lottery and Newsagents Association has called on the federal government to ease white paper import duties, after timber shortages blocked production at Australia’s last white paper mill in Victoria.

“There’s some rationing sort of going on around the amount that we can order but at the moment we’ve still got product on shelves,” association chief executive Ben Kearney told AAP.

“I’m concerned that down the line we might start to see that situation where there’s there’s a lack of availability.”

White paper production at Opal Australian Paper’s Maryvale mill was impacted in late December due to timber shortages after state-owned supplier VicForests was ordered to scale back harvesting in parts of Victoria.

The Victorian Supreme Court found VicForests failed to adequately survey logging coupes for two protected possum species.

VicForests is appealing against the decision, with a hearing in the Court of Appeal on March 23.

Office product companies have also called for an end to white paper import tariffs, as shortages push them towards foreign paper, Office Brands chief executive Adam Joy said.

“The tariffs were there to stop injury to the Australian manufacturing market, but there is no Australian manufacturing market at the moment but we’re all paying the tariffs,” Mr Joy told AAP.

The association and Office Brands said they were supportive of workers at Maryvale mill and hoped the supply disruption would be resolved as soon as possible.

The Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade and Minister for Industry Ed Husic have been contacted for comment.

The CFMEU is calling for an audit on the amount of white paper available in the country.

The manufacturing union flagged a potential shortfall in paper products including doctor scripts, exercise books and government services documentation.

“We don’t have a sense of how much white paper is actually available in the country at this point in time,” secretary of the pulp and paper workers district Denise Campbell-Burns told AAP.

“People could be going to the doctor and the doctor can’t print their script.”

Ms Campbell-Burns said removing tariffs would do nothing for sovereign capability.

“To not make any white paper products in our country anymore, it’s a real risk,” she said.

The CFMEU wants the Victorian and federal governments to intervene to reinstate production at Maryvale.

The disruption at Opal has led to 49 production workers being stood down, but their pay will be guaranteed by the Victorian government until mid-February.

Opal, owned by Japan’s Nippon Paper Group, said no decision on further stand downs had been made, but it was considering “scaling down” white paper manufacturing.

The company says it continues to consider different operational scenarios for the longer term, in case possible alternative wood sources are not feasible.

On Wednesday, Victorian Environment Minister Ingrid Stitt said talks were continuing between the government and Opal.

2 likes
Stationery

Check out the news agency at Amazon’s Whole Foods at Bryant Park in New York

It’s a store within a store, with the shingle: news agency, which I found kinda odd. It’s convenience focussed, with a few magazines.

The compressed newspaper wall at the entrance is cool but unnecessary.

I don’t get why they have done this. I mean, it reads as if they see value in the shingle, but then the shop inside has very little connection to it.

4 likes
retail

It’s too soon to discount calendars in some stores

Now that the traditional calendar discounters have closed for the year they rest of us in this space can hold to SRP and make good margin as those buying calendars now really want them.

I am seeing good calendar sales, especially now that Aussie homes and businesses are gearing up for the year.

Like with magazines, niche titles are working particularly well. This is a reminder as to the value of specialty focus. The supermarkets and others are the generalists. We can be the specialists and feel less price pressure as a result.

If this year is like others, calendar sales will continue to be good for another month or so.

1 likes
Calendars

A massive retailer shows how to embrace change

Even big businesses. In this short video I talk about Reddy, a pet shop unlike any I have seen, and share my surprise about the business behind it – showing how important innovation is.

How does this connect to newsagents? Retail is retail. Reddy focusses on millennial pet parents. Not pet owners. Not pet lovers. But pet parents. It treats them like that. And this makes a big difference in the engagement, and sits at the core of their success.

What Reddy is doing is, to me, and example of the need to play further outside the usual, and to do this in a local scale.

8 likes
retail

Whalebone is a magazine, a shop and an experience I enjoyed visiting

Whalebone on Bleeker Street in New York is a fascinating shop (?) to visit.

Once you step into the shop you are in their world, and what a wonderful, happy and warm world it is.

You just want to wander through, and explore.

This is fun retail, different retail, community engaged retail.

I am glad to have seen Whalebone while looking at innovative retail in New York in January 2023.

For some who pass by this place, this short video about Whalebone will hold no interest. I have shared it because it is magazine related and because it shows different retail, retail that plays outside the usual, and that’s very on trend now in local – playing outside the usual.

5 likes
retail