A blog on issues affecting Australia's newsagents, media and small business generally. More ...

SEO

Facebook not the platform for business we thought it would be

For a while now I have been questioning the value of Facebook as a marketing platform for business. Their constant changes of what shows in the news feed and changes to business rules have made the platform frustrating.

While it is terrific to get plenty of likes for your Facebook page and there are some who successfully use this to communicate with their customer community, there is a growing community of people concerned with where facebook is headed.

Mark Cuban, Chairman of the Dallas Mavericks and Chairman of HD Net, wrote about this recently at The Huffington Post. He gets to the heart of what Facebook in:

Facebook is what it is. It’s a time waster. That’s not to say we don’t engage — we do. We click, share and comment because it’s mindless and easy. But for some reason Facebook doesn’t seem to want to accept that its best purpose in life is as a huge time-suck platform that we use to keep up with friends, interests and stuff. I think that they are overthinking what their network is all about.

As far as a platform for reaching out to uncover new customers for any of my newsagencies, I am finding Twitter to be a far more useful and less costly platform. I am also able to more easily see the reach of what I put on Twitter than Facebook. That said, I’ll still use Facebook to connect with existing customers. We do live, after all, in a world with more routes to market than ever before.

I mention this today as there are social media experts pitching their service to newsagents, saying they can help you achieve plenty of likes for your newsagency Facebook page. Do your research before you go and give them money to achieve something that may be of questionable value.

9 likes
Newsagency management

Computerworld reports on our RSVP SEO search result complaint

Liz Tay has written a good story for Computerworld about the manipulation of Google results in favour of Fairfax’s RSVP dating site using our 3loves brand. Tay looks at all sides and has been successful in getting comments from most of those involved. I am happy with how she has covered the story.

Fairfax and Commission Monster, the Affiliate marketing company contracted by Fairfax / RSVP, claim to be victims of a rogue affiliate. I don’t know if that is true. All I know is that the campaign was running for at least two months before I outed it here and that Commission Monster and their trading partners ought to have discovered it themselves and stopped it.

0 likes
Blogging

Why would Fairfax / RSVP target my business?

I have been thinking about why Fairfax would allow an affiliate marketing campaign to run which specifically targets my 3loves free online dating website. (3loves is one of several sites we have launched to provide, in part, newsagents with access to some revenue from online advertising.)

While it is possible that Fairfax would not have known that an affiliate of Commission Monster – the affiliate services provider engaged by Fairfax – was running such a campaign, they ought to have known. Any business would want to know how their brand is represented in an advertising mix. Or, they ought to.

Anyway, why would Fairfax let this happen because it did happen, for at least two months? Not just to us but to a range of other tiny and not so tiny online dating sites. All these competitors of RSVP were targeted in a marketing campaign which was designed to move traffic to Fairfax’s RSVP site.

Profit is the answer. RSVP is highly profitable for Fairfax. It’s Australia’s largest online dating / personals site. Based on membership numbers and the charges for using some services on the site I’d suggest it is likely to be among the most profitable and therefore important to the Fairfax bottom line.

3loves is free. What RSVP charges for we offer free. We will always be free. 3loves exists to provide is a platform at which we can advertise Find It, our online classifieds site.

Even though 3loves is minuscule compared to RSVP, it must pose a risk. Why else would someone, either inside Fairfax, inside Commission Monster or elsewhere, specifically target 3loves? There is no reason other than a view that we, at some point, are a threat to RSVP.

What the last week has proven is the scams than are being used in the name of major brands, with their knowledge or without, in an effort to screw with Google, Yahoo and other search results. Some activities are outright scams. Others are done under the name of Search Engine Optimisation or as one could call it – Scam Everyone Online.

0 likes
Ethics