A blog on issues affecting Australia's newsagents, media and small business generally. More ...

retail

Price matching demands frustrating

pricematchA customer yesterday wanted to buy the Melway street directory but they wanted us to match the K-mart price. K-Mart had sold out. Our price was $4.00 more. I explained we don’t match prices but we do have a discount voucher opportunity in place for $$ off her next purchase. She rolled her eyes.

It turns out K-Mart had sold out and this was the last Christmas gift she had to purchase. While I could have discounted, I resisted because I don;t want to get caught up in the price matching game. She bought the street directory and then two boxes of cards in a second purchase.

I think price matching marketing is lazy. It can also be deceptive. Good retailers will offer a competitive price for their product / service offering. Poor retailers will say we’ll match and then either sell product you cannot easily compare and or discount to ride off the traffic generated by the marketing of others.

4 likes
Newsagency management

It’s a plush Christmas

xmaplushWe’re seeing excellent year on year sales of plush this Christmas season. While some sales have been to customers visiting to purchase cards or gifts, others have been to customers who know us as a plush destination. This is thrilling.

Achieving $750 and more in a day in plush sales is wonderful. Achieving it day in day out in the run down to Christmas is excellent. We could have achieved more had we not sold out of some lines – but that’s a good problem to have this close to Christmas.

We have created the plush results for ourselves as part of our business plan from mid 2012. Not only the sales ahead of plan, the net new traffic generated by the category is ahead of plan. It’s terrific seeing the business plan deliver these results.

The success with plush is a reason I prefer to focus on being a retailer in my businesses as opposed to being an agent. People are coming to us because of decisions we have made and actions we have taken. They are coming to us for us and not for a product or service over which we have little or no control as to where they get it, how much we make from it and or how much someone else promotes it.

The more of my business over which I have control the better for the future of my business.

Footnote: the photo reflects another reason for success with this category – our team creates displays that attract shoppers from within the shop. This line of colourful bears toward the back of the shop draws people further into the business. We’re always thinking beyond front of store displays. Attention to visual merchandising and product placement mid way through and at the rear of the store are just as important as the front window.

9 likes
Newsagency management

Older shoppers like the immediacy of discount vouchers

voucher-shopperLast weekend a customers spent up big, really big, and received a $30.51 discount voucher. Her response: I like this, I could be dead tomorrow. That’s what she said. She added: I could be, I’m ninety next year. She was a hoot!

We talked a bit more. She was serious about the value to her of the voucher versus points. She said that when you get to her age your horizon is closer and you think about the short term more. The points don’t work she said because of the long time often involved.

I’m confident this customer will be back in the next week to spend the voucher. If she is true to her word she will be bringing a friend.

The experience had me reflecting on shopper engagement with the vouchers. There is no doubt that older customers particular like them. Maybe my 89 year old customer is not alone in focussing on the closer horizon.

I loved that she explained her fatigue with the points based loyalty programs. She’s the type of shopper I’m targeting with these vouchers.

Every day we see examples of the vouchers driving loyalty and helping us to continue to achieve valuable year on year growth.

7 likes
Newsagency management

Leading shoppers with a retail trail

trailxmasSpace is a challenge this time of the year. You want to put just about everything out the front of the business to attract shoppers and sell but there is a shortage of room. Here’s something that I find works. We make a seasonal statement at each entry point and change this regularly. Then, a few steps away, we build on the statement. Then we build some more on it and so on. This invites customers to walk the path of the season without making the front of the business too top heavy. The last thing I want is my newsagency to look like a discount variety store as people who shop those are not loyal.

7 likes
Gifts

Negotiating a high street lease with the landlord

I have recently negotiated a lease extension with the landlord for a high street retail business I own and share the story here.

I nominated that I wanted to take up the extension permitted in the current lease. This triggered a market review opportunity for them which they embraced. The landlord engaged a single local real estate agent who came back arguing for a 10% increase with little hard evidence.  The double-digit rental increase was put to us by the solicitor for the landlord.

With the solicitor being difficult to deal with, I went back to the landlord explaining that I felt a fairer increase would be 5%. I explained that I had the option to reject their proposed increase through a more formal channel but would prefer to negotiate a middle-ground solution both parties could live with. I refused their argument of evidence form one real estate agent as being sufficient and reinforced that we had always paid on time and have been good tenants.

I was certain that QCAT would reject the landlord’s use of a single real estate agent and that the letter from the real estate agent did not, of itself, represent a fair market review.

After a couple of weeks consideration of my middle-ground proposal and several emails from me restating my case, the landlord agreed to the proposal of a 5% increase. While no increase can be considered to be good, it works in this situation. The business is tracking well and can digest the increase with much of what we sell not being fixed-price. Our approach is to chase more traffic, get existing traffic buying more and increasing our margin on all items through small steps on price.

I wanted to write about this today to encourage newsagents facing lease negotiations to be fair in their discussions with landlords, to always copy the landlord on any letter to their solicitor and to be clear in understanding what your next steps could be if you were to take a more formal dispute resolution approach.

While having a landlord who is committed to fairness is important, I think we can facilitate this in our approach to them when negotiating. They are entitled to ask for whatever increase they like. It’s where we end up that matters most.  Where we end up often depends on how we approach the negotiation.

Negotiating a lease with a high street landlord is completely different to negotiating with a shopping centre landlord.

8 likes
Newsagency challenges

Christmas changes drive traffic

christmaswgThe team at one of my newsagencies refreshed Christmas a couple of days ago, creating a zone focussing on single and boxed cards, plush and some decoration items. While previously we had all the product out, the various items were too far part, in different parts of the shop even … there was no focused Christmas pitch. Bordering the area with a terrific line of single cards and framing this around with Christmas themed categories, the result is a strong presence that is delivering a nice sales boost.

The placement of the large Hallmark plush items right at the front is excellent. Customers are drawn to them.

Christmas has kicked in early this year. sales are excellent.

5 likes
Newsagency management

Tampering with security is a reason for termination

I terminated the employment of someone this week because they deliberately disconnected the security camera located directly above a sales register. Their explanation was that the camera had been faulty and they were trying to fix it. The video evidence shows the camera working days prior to them reaching up and behind the camera and removing the cable that connects it to the recording device.

The wanted the camera off and the only reason could be one that compromises the business.

When it comes to business security we need to take a zero tolerance approach. Yes there are labour laws to respect. When it comes to casual employees we have some more flexibility.

8 likes
retail

Sheriffs clogging shopping centre car parks

As is shopping centre car parks in Australia are not busy enough this time of the year! Today at one shopping centre, several times I saw a court appointed sherif with lights flashing slowing moving past rows of cars checking number plates. If they find a plate that matches the computer system showing fines owed, the car is clamped.

While I understand governments want to collect their fines, they should not do it in such a way that disrupts retail, especially in a busy retail period! Click here and here for one of several stories showing this this really is a thing.

4 likes
retail

Mixed news for retail newsagents in September ABS data

The Australian Bureau of Statistics released retail performance data for the September quarter and the headline run by news outlets was overall good. For data about our channel you need to drill further into the ABS report:

OTHER RETAILING
In current prices, the trend estimate for Other retailing rose 0.1% in September 2013. The seasonally adjusted estimate rose 1.6%. By industry subgroup, the trend estimate rose for Pharmaceutical, cosmetic and toiletry goods retailing (0.4%) and Other recreational goods retailing (0.7%) and fell for Other retailing n.e.c. (-0.2%) and Newspaper and book retailing (-0.5%). The seasonally adjusted estimate rose for Pharmaceutical, cosmetic and toiletry goods retailing (3.1%), Other recreational goods retailing (2.4%) and Other retailing n.e.c. (0.4%) and fell for Newspaper and book retailing (-1.4%).

The state by state breakdown for overall retailing is interesting:

Turnover rose in New South Wales (1.0 per cent), Victoria (1.0 per cent), Queensland (0.8 per cent), South Australia (0.7 per cent), Tasmania (0.7 per cent), the Australian Capital Territory (0.7 per cent) and the Northern Territory (0.7 per cent). These rises were partially offset by a fall in Western Australia (-0.2 per cent). Over the longer term, Victoria was the strongest contributor to growth (up 0.5 per cent in trend terms).

The most important benchmark for newsagents is how their business performed this year compared to last year.

5 likes
Newsagency management

Retail business branding failure

branding-failCheck out the stationery business I saw in Auckland a couple of weeks ago – click on the picture. There was no stationery in this shop even though it is called Uptown Stationers. It was all tobacco, drinks, international phone calling cards and junk.

This shop gives stationers a bad name.

4 likes
retail

Cotton On’s Typo embraces Halloween

Check out the display promoting halloween product at a Typo (owned by Cotton On) store I saw in Brisbane two days ago. They only had limited stock left but the range was still good. Halloween has been picked up by more Aussie retailers this year than ever.

1 likes
Competition

Excellent Halloween display in Auckland

I love the chocolate coffins I saw in the window of one chocolate show in downtown Auckland earlier this week. Their Halloween display was excellent. It was made up of a series of small displays like this chocolate coffin display. Talking to a team member in the shop they have become known for their themed displays. People come to look at them. The team members get to make suggestions.

This is an excellent example of making an independent and small retail business a destination. Outside of these window displays this is an average chocolate shop – not meaning to put them down. Their window displays separate them and make them a shop to visit, to see what they are up to.

They are generating destination traffic, the most valuable form of traffic a retailer can have.

Click on the image for a bigger version.

5 likes
confectionary

One Direction overload at Coles

My local Coles supermarket is overloaded with One Direction product including these Advent Calendars. talking to one of the staff putting out more product they commented we can’t give it away. If true it’s good to hear.

0 likes
retail

Why discounting doesn’t move newsagency stock sometimes

No matter whether you are selling products at full price or discounting them you need to sell them. This means you need to merchandise them so the offer is compelling, easy to shop and appealing enough to attract browsers. This is especially true for products of style – such as the Top Model range.

The photo is from a newsagency I visited a couple of weeks ago. I’ve faded the edges and made it black and white so the source is not obvious since I am using the image only to illustrate my point and not finger the business.

If I was discounting a premium line like Top Model, which I am not, I’d do a bundled deal like buy three for two or even two for one or something along those lines.  A % off discount and stock dumped in crappy old dump bins disrespects the Top Model range and the business its in front of.

If something is not selling in your store you have to first off look at your own contributions to causing this situation. Just as we create our own success, we often create our own failure.

6 likes
Newsagency management

Mixing in the Halloween partwork

We’ve placed the Halloween themed issue of the Cake Decorating partwork in with our Halloween products display.The partwork helps pitch Halloween as a fun party opportunity and this helps sell some of the party related items we have for Halloween tis season.

2 likes
retail

Excellent book on shopper loyalty programs

I’ve just read Scoring Points by Clive Humby, Terry Hunt and Tim Phillips, the definitive book on retail shopper loyalty programs.  Scoring Points chronicles the introducation and finessing of the loyalty program at UK supermarket giant Tesco. I’d recommend this book to any retailer considering loyalty programs and how they might use them in their business. While written from the perspective of a big retailer, this book is just as relevant at our end of town.

While I must prefer the discount vouchers approach to loyalty, this book is about the broader shopper loyalty focus and how it’s vital every retailer play in this space.

3 likes
Newsagency management

Newsagency management tip: quit stock seriously

Harmony Bracelets have not worked for us. While we have sold 35% of our stock, the rest has sat for close to two months. This morning I made the decision to get out of the remaining stock this weekend and put the $9.95 bracelets on sale at $1.00.  Now, less than three hours in they’re selling very well. We should be done by the end of tomorrow. This frees floorspace for us, giving us an opportunity for a new product story.

Too often I see newsagents hold onto product for the sake of hoped-for margin in the future rather than discounting and taking the cash today. Okay so we have lost money on the bracelets. The loss I am realising today is less, I suspect, than the loss because of non-performing product taking up floorspace.

You can’t bank margin from products that don’t sell.

So, when I decide to quit an item I set pricing for it ti actually sell out.  The usual starting point is between 33% and 50% off. next is 75% and finally we move to a $$ price point. In the case of the Harmony Bracelets, their recent performance was such that I felt I needed to go straight to the $$ price point. hence the $1.00 price. It is also helping that school holidays have just started.

One customer bought 14 bracelets.

19 likes
Management tip

Three suppliers supporting late season AFL push

We’re using products from three different suppliers to support this aisle-end display promoting official AFL products. It’s faces into the front of the store and capping our magazine department.

I love that the in-store team has grouped items from multiple suppliers to tell a story. I also love that they have done this in a small footprint. Indeed, this display would work in newsagencies of all sizes.

I’ve noticed AFL product displays in several supermarkets over the last week so I’m comfortable we’re in this space at this time of the year too.

The lowest margin items on the display are the calendars from Network and we only have these out of necessity. Thankfully we’re achieving a fairer margin with our cards from Hallmark and the plush items.

3 likes
retail

Fun interactive impulse purchase items brighten up the newsagency

I watched on Thursday when a team member at one of my newsagencies demonstrated this Flash Sphere to a customer. Moments later the customer purchased two. The demonstration brightened the shop, taking it from a static display business to something fun an interactive.  Several shoppers in-store watched the demonstration – most were smiling.

Yesterday we sold more. We think we could be out of stock in a week. Now that’s a nice stock turn.

This is an excellent example of what’s important in retail today – engaging shoppers with our products. However, before we can do this we need to source products that work with such shop floor engagement.

To newsagents reading this saying there is no time for such games on the shop floor I’d say we need to find time as it’s this activity that drives basket depth and helps us provide a more memorable shopping experience.

6 likes
Newsagency opportunities

Terrific school holiday sales

We have had a terrific couple of weeks with school holidays. We have seen plenty of new shoppers in the centre. Our good sales have been driven by a front of store pitch that is not common for a newsagency. This opens us broader range of browsers.

I have included a photo to illustrate my point. (click on it)  You can see our focus on younger shoppers and those shopping the centre with and or for younger people. There is a small representation (far right) of magazines. The rest is plush,Beanie Kids, AFL products interactive toys and gifts – with a backdrop of greeting cards.

We are not doing anything special here, it’s basic retail – configuring the store to suit the opportunities of the season.

This type of work, generating new traffic for good margin product, is far more important for an newsagency business than taking on products or services that leech off existing newsagency traffic. I mention this because of current offers being put to newsagents that do this – leech … rather than generate new traffic.

The newsagencies that will do best from here on will be those generating new traffic for good margin product.

15 likes
Gifts

Coles using petrol outlets for click & collect online shopping

Coles Supermarkets has expanded its online shopping pick up offer with the opening of click and collect locations at shell petrol outlets. The photo shows the collection lockers at a Shell location at Garden City in Queensland.

Magazines are among the products Coles customers can purchase and collect using this service. In fact, I’ve seem magazines pitched as basket builders by both supermarkets.

Newsagents who say online will not affect their business do not understand the fundamental shift taking place in how and when people buy.

3 likes
Newsagency challenges

Chasing sales over the long weekend

The Queen’s Birthday weekend is one of the quietest weekends for retailers. Many retailers in a variety of retail channels tell me this is their experience.

This year, we are pursuing a change in the Queen’s Birthday experience in one of my newsagencies. We are running a campaign of 30% off all gifts and plush.

Our engagement in this campaign is putting into practice our belief that we make our own success.

While we could have been more selective and targeted only on the slower selling product, we decided to offer the discount on all gifts and plush so there is no doubt for shoppers. They can easily understand the pitch.  No fine print shows that we  reject the selective discounting game many retailers play.

The sale is for three days only, until the close of trade on Monday, so the risk is not great. Also, our buying on all gifts and plush is good, at better than average prices. Even at 30% off we’re in good shape.

Our artwork was created in house with a use of A3, A5 and A4 in-house printed posters and a couple of A1 posters printed offsite.  We deliberately chose yellow on black as it tested well at cutting through the sea of colour in the newsagency.

Care has been taken to dress the shop with collateral throughout – carefully placed to tell a story from entrance to exit, to drive shoppers visiting for one product category to consider other products on sale.

7 likes
Newsagency management