A blog on issues affecting Australia's newsagents, media and small business generally. More ...

Newsagency opportunities

Do newsagents need a newspaper distribution contract?

News and Fairfax are said to being close to putting new distribution contracts to newsagents for their consideration. The current contracts were negotiated in 1999 as part of the process of deregulation of newspaper and magazine distribution in Australia.

While newsagents and those who represent them will focus on the terms of the proposed contracts, I’d suggest newsagents first consider whether contracts are appropriate.

Distribution newsagents beat themselves up every day fulfilling their obligations under the current contracts for, in most cases, less than minimum wage.

Newsagents are paid less in real terms today for every newspaper they handle than ten years ago when the current contracts were negotiated. Newsagents cannot sustain themselves as the working poor.

By saying no to contracts we are saying no to being a distribution newsagent. This would be a big deal for most newsagents as we would be rejecting the very purpose for which our channel was created.

Not having a contract would give newsagents more freedom to define their own future. While many may fear such an opportunity, others have already found the freedom to be personally and financially rewarding.

I’d encourage newsagents and their associations to open debate on this and seriously question whether having a contract is important.

For the new contracts to be interesting, they need to improve compensation for newsagents and provide more local business control over the profitability of newspaper distribution. They would need to allow newsagents to be business people and not process workers.

0 likes
newsagency of the future

Podcast changes newsagent opinion about sales based replenishment

I have received some excellent feedback from newsagents who have listened to the first newsagency industry podcast which was published by Mediaweek last week and in which I participated.  The most significant feedback has been around ACP Magazines’ Sales Based Replenishment program.  Several newsagents commented to me that the podcast changed their opinion about SBR and that they now support the initiative.

I like SBR because it relies on good use of technology in newsagencies.  The reward for newsagents is eliminating sell-outs, especially for monthly titles which experience an unexpected spike in sales.

The podcast helped explain the benefit as well as some of the history to the latest incarnation of SBR.

0 likes
magazine distribution

Newsagency industry podcast

I participated last night in a podcast about the newsagency industry for Mediaweek magazine.  Moderated by Brenden Wood, Eugene Varricchio – Group General Manager – Retail & Distribution – ACP Magazines, James Manning – Editor – Mediaweek and I talked about magazines in the newsagency channel and the challenges we encounter and the opportunities ahead.  The 30 minute discussion started with a look at the issues surrounding the changes with Alpha magazine.

It is good to see the newsagency channel featured and discussed in this way.  As Eugene points out, we account for sales of mroe than 50% of ACP magazines product.

0 likes
magazines

Foreign newspapers up 13% Q1 2009

fhn_foreignpapers.JPGI am working through our own Q1 sales and found that once again foreign language newspapers were a stand-out success.  Unit sales are up 13% year on year at Forest Hill.  Other daily newspapers recorded a 0% change over the same period.  In Q1, we sold 867 foreign language newspapers.  We are achieving sales equal to around $12,000 per square metre of space allocated.  This is an excellent story.

0 likes
Newsagency opportunities

Q1 2009 newsagency sales benchmark study

I am undertaking a sales benchmark study comparing January-March 2009 against January-March 2008. Tower Newsagents can participate by sending a Monthly Sales Comparison report: tick the box to exclude home deliveries, and tick the box for a category breakdown. Set your first date range (on the left) to January 1, 2009 to March 31, 2009 and the date range of the right to one year earlier. Once the report is on the screen, click the PDF button to save this as a PDF, go into your email software and send a copy of the PDF to me at mark@tower… Newsagents not using Tower software should click here for a spreadsheet template. I’ll publish the benchmark results here and elsewhere so all newsagents can benefit.

UPDATE (3.50PM): I have now received sales data from 40 newsagencies.  I’d expect to have data from more than 100 by the end of the week.  This will be a good dataset.

0 likes
Newsagency opportunities

New magazine launch: Newsdoku

Australian newsagents today launch a new magazine to the Sudoku, Addoku, Kakuro and Crossword lovers of Australia. Newsdoku is a new type of puzzle, a WORLD FIRST. Each puzzle will take between four and twelve hours to complete and involves maths, detective skills and pure luck.

Modelled on the newsagents magazine allocations and accounting model used to supply magazine to newsagents, Newsdoku has a sting in the tail in that when you think you have got it right, the rules change and you are back to square one. If your game has not been cancelled in the meantime.  While the usual game will run for a month, some run for six months.  Others come back again and again even when you have done them because everyone knows we cannot get enough of a good things.

You can call the national Newsdoku help line for help but this results in penalty points and the loss of time – and their advice has a 50/50 chance of heading you down the worng path for which you will be responsible and not the national help line.

Ask your local newsagent about Newsdoku. It will be in the back room.

0 likes
Newsagency opportunities

The opportunity of change for newsagents

I have been asked by some newsagents who attended my presentation at the QNF State Conference last week for a copy of the slides.  I have loaded them to Slideshare.  Click on the image below to play the presentation.

Unfortunately, without the commentary some slides won’t make sense.  The abridged version is this: we are in the midst of massive change.  Rather than ignoring this, embrace it, do something, change your business. I am optimistic about the future because there are many proactive newsagents building new business models – some of which I discuss in the presentation.

0 likes
Newsagency opportunities

Newspaper subscription offers for retail customers

I wish newspaper publishers in Australia supported the over the counter subscription system like the have in the UK.  Read how these subscriptions operate with The Guardian:

How does Guardian and Observer Subscriber work?
The subscription scheme is based on a voucher system. We will send you personalised, dated vouchers for each day of your package. You simply detach the appropriately dated voucher and hand it to your retailer as payment for your copy of the Guardian or Observer. You will receive a new set of dated vouchers every three months. Your retailer will be fully reimbursed for the full price of your newspaper.

Where are my Guardian and Observer vouchers accepted?
Most local newsagents, major supermarkets and petrol stations will accept your subscription vouchers as payment for your Guardian and Observer newspaper. If you have a problem using your voucher then please contact us on 0845 1204733 9am to 5pm seven days a week. Calls charged at local rate

My local newsagent already delivers my papers. Can I still subscribe and benefit from the saving?
Yes you can. If your local newsagent already delivers your papers to your home, simply hand your Guardian and Observer Subscriber vouchers for the relevant month to your retailer and these will be put towards your bill. Please note that you will need to arrange home delivery of your papers directly with your newsagent who may charge you for this service. Home delivery is not part of the Subscriber scheme.

While I am sure there would be some bumps with implementation, something along the lines of what The Guardian offers would drive sales more days of the week.  I have pitched this several times over the last few years and failed.  Maybe others here, if they like the idea, could pitch it to their publisher contacts.

0 likes
Newsagency opportunities

NSW/ACT Newsagent of the Year Awards

dsc06673.JPGCongratulations to NANA for a good night last night at their Newsagent of the Year Awards.

Congratulations and kudos too to the stars of the evening – Van Nguyen Tuan Tra of Wincamden Newsagency for winning the Distribution Newsagent of the Year Award and Allen and Brenda Kavanagh of Greenhills Newsagency for winning Retail Newsagent of the Year award.

More than 160 people attended the event – a show of tremendous support for the work of NANA.

The photo shows the businesses which financially supported the Awards dinner.  This includes my own Tower Systems.  I mention the sponsors because the suppliers supporting newsagent events demonstrate, financially, their commitment to the channel – support them.

0 likes
Newsagency opportunities

Suppliers supporting newsagents

Here are the suppliers who funded the QNF Queensland Newsagent State Conference the event yesterday.

supportingnewsagents.jpg
As one who regularly supports such events through newsXpress and Tower Systems, it is frustrating that it is the same suppliers who stump up cash for newsagent conferences, golf days and the like. The best way newsagents can encourage more suppliers to open their wallets is to support the suppliers who fund industry events.

0 likes
Newsagency opportunities

Meeting Queensland newsagents

dsc06648.JPGI am grateful to have had an opportunity to speak at the QNF Queensland Newsagents State Conference today. I spoke on Living with Google – how we need to operate our newsagencies in this Google dominated world where the traditional business rules have been abandoned and our core products are challenged. I see our response to the changed world in simple terms:

  • Take responsibility. We need to be responsible for our businesses. This means NOT relying on suppliers or others to lead us. We have to lead ourselves – individually and collectively as appropriate to our circumstances. Too many newsagents have bought into the channel in pursuit of an income. Those who have bought in to own and operate a business will fare better.
  • Stand for something. Most newsagents stand for vague points of difference – customer service, being local etc. Each of us needs to stand for something of value, something which defines every decision we make.
  • Take control of our retail space. We need to reject supplier control of our space – unless they pay the rent.
  • Take control of our product mix. We need to control what we sell – suppliers cannot do this for us.
  • Take control of our message. We need to be clear in our message and it needs to reflect what we stand for.
  • It all comes down to change. Our business model is based on old products and old business principles. While the old products will serve us well for some time, we need to transparently and urgently start to change. We should do this in beta – trial and error – and in consultation with our customers. Our customers will be more useful in guiding our future than our existing suppliers.

I met several people at the QNF Conference who are excited to be pushing the boundaries of their newsagencies. They have every right to be excited.
The biggest challenge we have as a channel is the gap emerging between the newsagents changing their businesses and those who do not understand that change is essential.

0 likes
Newsagency opportunities

Optimistically embracing the global economic crisis

I have been contemplating the future of newsagencies in the context of the GEC (Global Economic Crisis) ahead of my speech today to the Queensland Newsagents State Conference. I’ve been reading plenty about the GEC and the likely impact on businesses like ours, about how retailers traded through the Great Depression and other tough economic cycles.

I am optimistic. If we are smart, newsagents have a bright future. The GEC is an opportunity for us, an opportunity to celebrate being small, local (Australian) and flexible.

  • Being small. Smart newsagents will exploit the opportunity by making quick decisions big businesses are slow (too big) to make. Decisions like changing range, price and positioning.
  • Being local. Smart newsagents will promote their Australianness and the convenience of their location – and do so in the wake of non-locally connected bigger retailers. Newsagencies are in every town yet we do not promote that our excellent geographic positioning saves fuel and time through convenient shopping.
  • Being flexible. Smart newsagents will take their businesses from being newsagencies to being – convenience stores, gift shops, stationery retailers, cafes. They will play with the model in pursuit of what is right for their local situation.  Most of all, they will reduce the space allocation for products over which they have no control.

Of course, if we do nothing then we become spectators of the passing opportunity.

We will get more from our businesses if we engage and participate in the GEC.

0 likes
Newsagency opportunities

Star Wars Official collectors models popular

fhn_starwars.JPGThe Star Wars Official collectors models partwork has been out three days and has already sold very well.  Even though we received almost no marketing collateral we have given the title prime space at the entrance to our blokes magazine aisle.  We know this title will appeal to our customers.  While partworks have their challenges, they are efficient titles for us to sell – basket data shows that partworks customers are more likely to purchase other items when collecting the latest edition.

UPDATE: We sold out in our newsagencies today and are chasing extra stock for back orders.  This is a very successful launch.

0 likes
Newsagency opportunities

How Express Publications hinders top selling magazines

dsc06484.JPGFurther to my post yesterday about the inefficiency of the magazines from Express Publications, the photo shows the titles with which their Home magazine competes.

Better Homes and Gardens, Notebook, Real Living, Melbourne Living and Vogue Living all play in the same space except that they are real magazines – they are efficient in use of space, are promoted professionally and are retail friendly.  However, these titles compete with various Express titles for space and cash.

Maybe the publishers of these titles could work with newsagents in finding a solution to the space and cash draining Express Publications problem.  Too often publishers turn a blind eye to bad behavior from other publishers to their ultimate detriment. They could work with newsagents and help us stop companies from abusing our channel.

0 likes
magazines

Life with Google for newsagents

I am speaking at the QNF Queensland Newsagent’s State Conference on Tuesday next week. I have chosen to speak on: Life with Google: How Google impacts on newsagencies already and how we can embrace the opportunities of a Google world.

While I don’t have the answers, I do hope to open a conversation among newsagents about their future and opportunities of change presented to us.

Google itself is not the challenge, more the catalyst for much needed change in how we structure and operate our businesses.  But rather than speak of challenges, I’ll explore opportunities.  There are newsagents with flourishing businesses – each one of these started with identifying an opportunity.

0 likes
Newsagency opportunities

Fleeing cheap stationery

As we see more retail evolution in our space – OFIS closing, Officeworks tweaking their model, others moving in and out of products newsagents sell – our role as independent retailers will change.  Or, at least, there is opoportunity for us to embrace change.  While our major competitors will play more with house brands, we can embrace known brands, brands which are advertised widely, brands which can help newsagents grow stronger retail businesses.

I suspect that from a consumer perspective we are entering a time where brand matters more and where cheap China imports are not as sought after by customers and some newsagents as they used to be?

I was talking with a newsagent yesterday who for several years has purchased cheap Chinese stationery and gift related lines for his shop.  He has merchandised these as you would see in a discount store.  He enjoyed making money from cheap tennis balls and trinkets.

Since things got tougher economically, sales of this cheap China product have fallen.  I think it is because consumers are felling cheap in pursuit of value.  Value comes from known brands.  Newsagents I speak with who have a solid brand strategy are finding stationery sales good – holding their own or even growing.

I’d expect to see newsagents who have focused on cheap China product to shift focus this year and join the brand-based movement.  There is excellent research indicating that consumers flee to known brands in tough times.

I am glad that for ink and toner I’ve only focused on brands like HP, Canon, Epson and Brother and that for stationery I have focused on Post-It, Scotch,  and other brands well-known and regularly advertised to consumers.

We are seeing that we can compete with branded product.  The more we embrace brands as a channel the better our negotiating position – there are only so many wholesalers through which we purchase after all.

0 likes
Newsagency opportunities

Happy St Patrick’s Day

st_pats.JPGIn addition to traditional St Patrick’s Day cards, Hallmark has provided this and some other fun cards.  Our St. Patrick’s Day card sales have been good – we are getting known for these smaller card seasons.

St Patrick’s Day is the big day, one day of the year, for the Irish Echo newspaper.  Unlike other ‘foreign’ newspapers, the Irish Echo struggles in my newsagency except for around March 17.

This day is good for some retail theatre – in newsagencies especially.

0 likes
Greeting Cards

March newsagency sales numbers

How’s business?  This is a question often asked between newsagents.  I have created a new category on this blog for irregular posts I’ll make about month to date to year to date business performance.  This will hopefully open more conversations between newsagents about how they are trading.

To the close of business last night, March 15, here are our numbers for March 2009 compared to 2008:

  • Magazines. Down 13%.  Women’s weeklies down 6%.
  • Lottery products.  Down 15%.
  • Ink. Up 15%.  HP accounts for 73% of sales.
  • Newspapers.  Up 2%.
  • Stationery.  Up 32%.
  • Cards.  Line ball.  Non seasonal – up 5%.  Easter was earlier last year.
  • Stamps.  Up 91%.
  • Art.  Up 18%.
  • Copying.  Up 5%.
  • Gifts.  Up 415% – off a low base.

All percentages are based on unit sales except for stataionery, ink, gifts and lottery products.

Magazines is our biggest department by far – the financial pain of the sales fall is significant.  As regulars here will know, we promote magazines aggressively and certainly pursue a point of difference around range.

0 likes
How is business?

Promoting 2009 season AFL cards

fhn_afl_select.JPGThe 2009 Select AFL Champions cards were launched today and we are promoting the cards and album at our premium counter point.

Endorsed by the AFL and the Players Association, the cards have always been a good seller for us.  Based on sales so far of other AFL related products this year, I’d expect sales of the Select cards to be up on last year – hence our opportunistic high traffic area display.

One reason we like these and other AFL collectible cards is that they are habit based product.  They will bring people back – as long as they associate our shop with satisfying their interest.  To anchor our place in their minds we work hard to ensure that we have enough stock for long into the season.

0 likes
Newsagency opportunities

Watching the moves of book retailers

Newsagents ought to be watching the moves at Borders, Waterstones and Barnes and Noble.  They are busy evolving their models, redefining their businesses.  Barnes & Noble just bought Fictionwise, an e-book retailer.  Borders is launching a new e-reader.  Waterstones has done a deal to be the exclusive retailer for the new Glen David Gold novel, Sunnyside.  In fact, they have done much more than this in the last few weeks.  They are cutting deals and making strategic decisions in pursuit of their future.

They are disrupting their own businesses.  This is what we should be doing, competing with our traditional businesses.  While some newsagents are, the vast majority are not.  This is a huge risk for the future of our channel.  Disruption is going on around us – newspaper readers are getting satisfaction online, so are magazine readers and lottery customers.  These are key traffic generators for us.

Each of us needs a plan.  It has to come from us and it has to have our businesses at its heart.  no one else will do this for us, certainly not most who claim to represent newsagents – most of them just don’t get what leadership is about.

Smart booksellers are worth watching.  Their moves can awaken and motivate us.

0 likes
Book retailing

Staples rebrands Corporate Express in Canada

Staples announced this week that it will rebrand its Canadian Corporate Express operation as Staples Advantage Canada.  I’d expect to eventually see the Staples name here in Australia  and with that more of a consumer focus applied to the traditional Corporate Express offering.  Such a move would shake-up stationery retail here – hence the need for us to work on our own stationery offering.  Staples acquired Corporate Express in July 2008.

0 likes
Newsagency opportunities

Easter card and gift sales strong

eascards.jpgGoing out early with Easter cards and gifts is paying off – sales are good.  I’d be surprised if we are not more than 10% up on last year by the time we reach Easter Sunday in April.  Easter is a feel-good season so sales growth amid the doom and gloom stories makes sense.  Easter is also a season around which newsagents can promote their local-shopping credentials – helping shoppers buy locally and save and support the local economy.  We need to promote more around the local themes – newsagencies are ideal businesses for this.

0 likes
Greeting Cards

Free local newspaper for Victorian bushfire areas

phoenix.jpgA free local newspaper. The Phoenix, covering Victoria’s Bushfire affected areas has been launched by the company behind the Melbourne Observer newspaper. The Phoenix will be primarily distributed through newsagencies in fire affected areas including Nillumbik, Whittlesea, Murrindindi, Mitchell and Yarra Ranges – 100 outlets in all.  Once again newsagents are playing an important community role.

Each issue of The Phoenix will carry free advertising listings businesses in the bushfire affected areas. The Melbourne Observer office is providing free backup support for calls and faxes in addition to underwriting production costs.

The Phoenix is a terrific initiative for the newsagents in bushfire affected areas and the wider community.

0 likes
Newsagency opportunities