The newsagency brand is in trouble. Right there, in that sentence, is the problem: Newsagency is not a brand. It used to be. For over 100 years it was the brand on main street. The newsagent was someone special and the business the go to place for stationery, newspapers, magazines and cards.
In the 1970s and 1980s as more shopping malls opened and some main streets started to fade, newsagencies started to lose consistency. The push of newspapers and magazines into other outlets in the 1980s, 90s and this century has driven fading consistency in newsagencies.
Years ago, industry associations tried to reinforce this by creating the N logo. The idea of the N logo was to make it a mechanism for discipline. That failed a few years ago and it is to late not to apply discipline which has been treated so poorly by so many.
My view that newsagency as a brand is no longer was reinforced this week when I visited three newsagencies in the space of two hours and saw three very different businesses. One was a dirty dingy trash heap which should be closed, the other a stunning business and the third a shop more focused on cheap product from China than traditional newsagency lines. While these businesses are entitled to call themselves what they like, good newsagents would cringe that two of the three share the newsagency shingle.
So, the newsagency brand is dead. Smart newsagents will brand themselves as something else, something which is backed with appropriate discipline and which can separate their business from the two newsagencies I saw earlier this week.
This is why marketing groups are essential to the future of the channel. Marking groups have the mechanisms of discipline – franchise agreements and the like. One of the reasons I joined newsXpress is for the discipline. I had been in a couple of groups before where there was no discipline. To me, a marketing group must have balls to toss out members who do not meet standards – otherwise the brand is weak – just as the newsagency shingle is weak.
Newsagents who are not part of a marketing group are relegated to being grouped with others trading under the newsagency shingle. In that group you have some of the best newsagents in the country and some of the worst and therein lies the problem.