A blog on issues affecting Australia's newsagents, media and small business generally. More ...

Diaries

Collins Debden pitches its diaries direct to consumers

It is challenging seeing a supplier you have supported for years go out with a direct to consumer pitch. I didn’t plan to write about Collins Debden today. An email from them this morning caught my attention.

This is a Collins Debden direct to consumer pitch.

They added me to their marketing database, without my permission. Their email includes a compelling offer:

They end with a offer of social media connection. If only they were this engaged with small business retailers of their products.

I am surprised that they are promoting direct to consumers when they are so far behind with shipping to retailers. Their fulfilment processes are strained and unable to get product to shops on time. Why would an individual feel they could fulfil a single order on time, unless Collins Debden is prioritising their direct to consumer orders. I have no idea whether that is the case tho.

I am tired of suppliers going direct after years and decades of support from retailers like us to drive brand awareness and engagement. They could not go direct as they have if we had not supported as we have.

A supplier going direct demonstrates disrespect for their retail partners. Them doing this while they are party to delays in supply to retailers is appalling. It is a failure of social responsibility on their part.

Thinking about this issue of a supplier going direct more generally …

There are ethical considerations to consider when a long-term supplier decides to go direct-to-consumer.

  • Fairness and Trust: The supplier’s decision may impact local retail businesses, potentially leading to lost sales or revenue. A good supplier will be on the front foot and engage in open communication on how to mitigate any negative effects. A bad supplier will make the move and not discuss it with retailers.
  • Customer Relationships: Customers may be confused or disappointed by the change. We need to be transparent and communicate clearly with them to maintain trust and loyalty to our business. We need to tell them what has been done to us.
  • Competition: The supplier is likely now a direct competitor, impacting your market position. Consider how you can differentiate your business and offer unique value to your customers. Look for alternative products that will serve your customers.

Ultimately, the ethical approach involves maintaining open communication, acting with integrity, and prioritising the needs of your customers.

15 likes
Diaries

Collins Debden 2025 diary supply challenges are hurting sales

We are missing out of revenue from the certain sale of Collins Debden diaries as a result of supply challenges within the Collins Debden business. I have heard from plenty of newsagents in the same situation.

Approaches to the company over the last two months have resulted in what I’d describe as spin. They have not resulted in any stock being delivered, which is frustrating since Amazon Australia appears unaffected by the supply challenges.

That Amazon has stock of what newsagents could be selling right now opens the question of whether the supply delay is part of a recalibration of the go-to-market strategy at Collins Debden. I this is a reasonable question to have when you see a major competitor of stock while yuou have no indication of when your stock will arrive.

While some newsagents have covered diary sales by accessing stock elsewhere, most cannot since the typical diary shopper is brand loyal. That brand loyalty will see them buy wherever they can find the Collins Debden diary they want. This is where Amazon having stock plays out negatively for newsagents. I first heard about Amazon being able to supply from a customer who was frustrated that we did not have stock.

With newsagents aware of cost to their business from the lack of supply by Collins Debden, I anticipate there will be claims against the company for lost sales as well as claims for financial support to move diaries when they do finally arrive. In my opinion, the company would do well to thoughtfully consider how it supports local small business retailers who have been without stock now for close to two months while a major competitor, Amazon, has had stock.

How Collins Debden handles the situation, outside of fixing the supply issues, will speak to the interest the company has in its local small business retailer network. I know plenty of retailers will be watching the situation. I wonder, too, whether there are any matters for regulators here. For example, if there is evidence of preferencing a big retailer (Amazon) over local small business retailers, could that be captured in regulations supporting small businesses.

Like all newsagents who regularly stock Collins Debden diaries, the best solution would have been on time supply and the second best solutions would have been diaries supplied a few weeks late. As of this morning, we are considerably beyond that, with the situation made worse by inadequate communication from the company.

18 likes
Diaries

Strong diary sales in the newsagency already

2022 is set to be a busy year if diary sales are anything to go off. We have had diaries out for a few weeks and sales are ahead of 2020 and the all important 2019 (given that last year was odd). Like, way ahead.

Like many newsagents, we have a good range, which we are pitching mid way into the store. We have done a bit on social media but not much. I mention this to note that diary sales are primarily to people seeking them out.

Even though our general stationery sales are way down, because we have ranged that department to be that way, diaries are a focus because they connect with other categories and because they make good gifts. We pitch them this way, too … as gifts and connected with other categories such as journals, notebooks and similar.

3 likes
Diaries

Specialty diaries pitch a point of difference

With trains continuing to be popular across generations in magazine, jigsaw, calendar, toy, card, gift and other product category formats of the business, it makes sense to pitch a train focussed diary for 2020.

This Great Trains of Australia 2020 diary from the Last Diary Co. is a perfect product for out of store marketing for us, to reinforce the business as a destination for train lovers and those who buy gifts for them.

Our ability to pitch specialisation begins with the product we source. In my own businesses,  key questions we ask when considering an individual product or a category are: does it reach a an easily understood and appreciated specialty niche and does it lend itself to o9ur of store marketing.

We are especially interested in fringe interests often ignored by major retailers for it is in this space where we can find valuable shoppers.

9 likes
Diaries

Successful diary promotion on Facebook

This simple and colourful post on Facebook worked exceptionally well for us. In addition to terrific online engagement, we saw action in-store as a result. What I love the most is that the product gave us a way to pitch diaries in a way that was more engaging, more successful.

The post is from over a week ago. The engagement data shows it to be one of the most successful promotions in months.

Simple is best when it comes to social media.

8 likes
Diaries

Advice for small business newsagents on how to win more diary business

Newsagents used to be the biggest retailer of diaries in Australia. That has not been the case for some years.

You only have to go into an Officeworks to see an extraordinary pitch for diaries. Calendar Club, too, are in this space. Plus we have Typo, Kikki.k, discount variety stores, K-Mart, Target and supermarkets. Then there is online – from websites in Australia and overseas.

Looking online, I found diaries for a raft of special interest niches available at less than Australian recommended retail and with free delivery from overseas websites.

It is a tough challenge for newsagents to win back the diary business. But we have to try. The channel has to try. The alternative we we mark this down as another loss for us. We should not stand for that.

Here are some management and marketing tips for newsagents to win back diary business:

  • Display differently. Create something beautiful, eye-catching. Colour block.
  • Feature diaries, showing off features in a creating way to grab attention.
  • Use social media. Run a series of posts showing information about diaries, show off your knowledge. Pitch yourself as the local expert.
  • Pitch range. Show your range in a way that pitches you as having the biggest local range.
  • Use a secondary location. Near weekly magazines or newspapers. Get your regular shoppers considering diaries thanks to tactical placement in-store.
  • Offer multi-buys. Consider packaging multiple diaries in a pack to make price comparison difficult. For example, a small pocket diary with a desk diary.
  • Host a diary party. Some people are very committed to their diaries. If you can find them this could be a fun event. Put on some drinks and food to make it special. Can you think of any other business nearby hosting such an event? Probably not. And this is the reason for you to do it.
  • Run a short term sale. For, say two days. 25% off. Run it now and call it an early bird sale. This is particularly useful if you have shoppers who may, later in the season, purchase elsewhere.
  • Feature new diaries in store now. As you get new product, shout out about it to show your range has expanded.
  • Train your staff. Make everyone a diary expert.
  • Find the oldest diary. Ask your customers for the oldest diary they have and get ti in-store for a promotion.

My hope is these ideas get you thinking of ideas for yourself.

Diary sales growth is here for the taking for small business newsagents. If you do what you usually do your results will be in line with your past trajectory. If you are happy with this, don’t change. If you want to do better then you need to do better.

Good luck and let’s all work to win more diary revenue for newsagents this season.

13 likes
Diaries

Retro diary helps reach more people for calendars

IMG_2105We are leveraging this retro themed 2017 diary from Universal as a call out to people who might otherwise think of diaries as bland and boring rather than connecting with a passion. This diary is an excellent example of an opportunity for promotion on social media and elsewhere to combat blindness to the possibilities of what people will find in your shop.

3 likes
Diaries

Driving diary sales in the newsagency

IMG_1675Someone asked recently about why our diary sales were strong. We went out early with financial year diaries and then into 2016 diaries. What helps is that the display itself has to be walked around to get to the back end of the store where we have newspapers, magazines and stationery. Also, card shoppers come down their main aisle and pass diaries on the way to the counter.

Traffic direction is a key to sales being up 196% year on year off a good base.

The photo is from this morning. It shows one side of this diary display and does not show a secondary location.

9 likes
Diaries

Diary season in the newsagency

IMG_9681We are promoting our range of 2016 diaries mid way into the newsagency, in front of the magazine department. This location worked well for us with Financial Year diaries this year – our sales were up 47% this year on the back of a solid base.

The display in the photo is one of two of diaries in-store. The second is close to this display. It is placed so those leaving the magazine aisle heading to the counter pass.

Shopping basket data analysis shows magazines and diaries are often purchased together in the newsagency. I use analysis such as this to guide ranging, product placement and other business decisions.

I urge newsagents to undertake the type of basket analysis I describe for themselves as each business can perform differently. This is simple using newsagency software – it should take a minute or two to create a basket analysis report for the last year. I think a year of analysis is reasonable for the types of decisions I am discussing here.

I am a firm believer that we make our own success in our newsagencies as in any small business. Success starts with good data and is facilitated by thoughtful analysis of your own business data and acting on what the data guides.

9 likes
Diaries

Promoting the Australian Women’s Diary 2016

IMG_8784While we have the Australian Women’s Diary 2016 edition in a couple of locations, this location above worm’s magazines is where it will work best based inputs experience.  I urge you to place at least one unit with women’s magazines ASAP to make the most of the opportunity. We achieve good sales early in the diary buying cycle.

6 likes
Diaries

How are your financial year diary sales?

IMG_6821Financial year diaries are important to newsagencies as we are the first place many shoppers shop. Compared to Back to School when people come to us last, I am finding that for financial year diaries plenty come to us first. They represent terrific business sin terms of destination traffic and basket-deepening impulse purchases.

For a modest inventory investment and space commitment the return is well worth it.

What do others think?

5 likes
Diaries

Encouraging diary sales in newsagencies

Screen Shot 2014-12-30 at 8.06.19 pmI was pleased to see the tweet from Collins Debden about diaries and had to respond to them to encourage their promotion of newsagencies as the go to retailers for diaries. We need to embrace every social media opportunity possible to promote our channel.

5 likes
Diaries

Customers will travel to a newsagency that has what they want

frankiesearchWe have customers travelling through many suburbs to shop with us because they know we stock the Frankie diary. Having travelled for this purchase, they often shop the shop and select other items they like. We deliberately source items to interest the Frankie customer not just at Christmas but all through as is a demographically important and commercially successful magazine title for us.

What we are doing here is a good example of how newsagents can use magazines to grow sales of other products under a popular magazine brand and unbranded products that will appeal to those who like the title.

We have been stocking the diary for some years along with the calendar and other items published under the Frankie brand. We chased the publisher and they ensured we got stock through the distributor.

I understand the temptation to say that it is a lot of work to do for one or two diary sales. To that I’d say it is not just one or two diary sales. Our basket analysis indicates it is considerably more than that. Our goal is to continue to evolve our offering to show the Frankie diary shopper that there are other reasons they should drive across suburbs during the year to shop with us and not just now for the diary.

We can grow our newsagency businesses by seeking out the hard to get products our customers are prepared to travel for. Sure it takes some work … the rewards are worth it!

6 likes
Business planning

Welcome Women’s Weekly Health Diary traffic

healthdI love it when a customer comes in and asks specifically for an item, something that has driven them to us. This is happening regularly at the moment for the Women’s Weekly Health Diary. I appreciate the traffic for the product – generated in part by good and wide promotion of the product recently.

One customer shared a but much Saturday saying I get all my magazines at Coles now and I thought they’d have this there. I smiled, thanked them for their business and pointed out the discount voucher they now had from us for spending on magazines from us.

2 likes
Diaries

Diary sales in the newsagency up 160%

diariesOur 2015 diary sales are up 160% compared to sales of 2014 diaries to the same time last year. This is off a good base.

The one change this year over last is the placement of some diaries in front of newspapers and magazines. We have the space for this placement following the removal of two magazine fixtures a few weeks ago.

While Collins diary sales are up it is our fashion diaries that are benefiting the most. They are located on the other side of the table – out of view in the photo.

We source diaries from several suppliers covering business and personal needs. Stock starts out on the floor in August and builds in September.

Our experience this year is that placement is key to driving diary sales.

6 likes
Diaries

Newsagents frustrated at journal supply

journalI’ve heard from several newsagents about the Paper Pocket branded journals received today from Network Services.  These are from Universal Magazines. They are part of the calendar offer newsagents were given the opportunity to opt out of. Billing is delayed. While they are 33% margin, that’s short of where they need to be to be interesting to many newsagents. I have suggested to Universal that instead of opt out, they go with opt in. They are reviewing distribution plans for next year.

The products themselves look good. It’s the terms and the push model that frustrate newsagents.

8 likes
Calendars

Excellent Women’s Health Diary sales

healthdiaryWe’re seeing excellent Australian Women’s Health Diary sales from our stand placed directly above our weekly magazines. This location is working the best for us – even better than stock placed with diaries. We chose the weekly magazine location to pitch the diary to people who are likely to purchase it on impulse.

2 likes
Diaries

Are you leveraging your Downton Abbey opportunity?

I am curious about where newsagents place the Downton Abbey diary. I’ve put it with People’s Friend and magazines targeting an older shopper as this seemed the most logical location. I have stock with diaries but felt that I am more likely to get an impulse purchase if I place this with the type of shopper most likely to be watching the hit TV series.

Don’t do this tactical placement just for Downton Abbey diaries. Look for more opportunities.

2 likes
Diaries

Act now to promote 2015 diaries

Now is the time to include a reminder on a September or October page in the 2014 diaries on your shop floor telling shoppers to collect their next diary from you. This subtle reminder can generate excellent traffic for you. The small stickers are cheap to produce and only takes a few minutes to put in place – and they don’t damage the 2014 diary. Put the sticker on a weekend day.

3 likes
Diaries

Megan Gale promoting newsagents

It’s great to see Megan Gale supporting newsagents and the Astro Diaries that we have available exclusively through our channel (from Universal Magazines). As I blogged last month, these diaries came with billing delayed for the entire on-sale period.

Megan Gale’s support of us to her 90,000+ Twitter followers is on the back of other excellent traction for this product and the newsagency channel.

The supply model followed by Universal – giving newsagents more control over supply and terms that serve the sales cycle of the product – is one other publishers could follow.

3 likes
Diaries

2014 Phantom diary supply a waste

I early returned our supply of 2014 Phantom diaries because of poor margin, poor payment terms, high cover price (high cost to us of theft), that Phantom sales are low for us and our diary offer is full with high margin product we selected for ourselves.

We should have been invited to order what we wanted.

We did not top the product as we could have – we sent back full copies.

4 likes
Diaries

Promoting Astro Diaries from Universal Magazines

I’m pleased we took the floor display unit of 2014 Astro Diaries from Universal Magazines that I blogged about recently. We have the unit on the shop floor between the magazines and newspapers and the sales counter. We also have stock placed with our other diaries. I like the product because it feels worth the $19.95 price, is a newsagency channel exclusive and should sell for us.

5 likes
Diaries

2014 Astro Diaries opportunity for newsagents

Universal Magazines is releasing a premium diary for 2014 exclusively through the newsagency channel. I’ve seen the product. It’s high-end, and ideal gift. Newsagents can control supply. You can also request a floor display unit. I’m ordering this for my newsagencies as it fills a valuable niche.

Here’s information from Universal about the Astro Diaries:

  • The Astro Diaries are really two products in one, Each of the 12 Astro different Astro Diaries combines the usefulness of a week to view Diary planner with the fun of a monthly Astrology overview and daily prediction.
  • Finished size 210X200mm case bound with magnetic close flap
  • RRP $19.95
  • Exclusive to newsagents
  • Delay billed for the whole on sale period – No cash outlay-
  • 33% retail commission
  • Full sale or return
  • Our research suggests the Astro Diaries will be a popular gift line this year as they are unique, fun and represent exceptional value as a gift Supplied through Network Services
  • Available to retail 19/9/2013

While I’m promoting the diaries I have no commercial arrangement with Universal Magazines. My support is because I think this product offers an excellent opportunity for newsagents.

4 likes
Diaries