A blog on issues affecting Australia's newsagents, media and small business generally. More ...

Australia Post

Australia Post branded ATMs

australia_post_atm_smelb.jpgSticking out of the window of the Australia Post shop on Park Street South Melbourne is an Australia Post branded ATM.  This ATM has appeared in an area well serviced with ATMs by banks and other commercial operators.

There was no need for Australia Post to enter a well serviced marketplace, no need for this government owned monopoly to leverage its protected name and status to take business from private enterprise.

This is what Australia Post has been doing for years – under successive Governments.  There appears to be no stopping of the extent to which this wholly Government owned and protected enterprise will go to take revenue from the private sector.

The only value associated with this ATM is the Australia Post brand.  The Australia Post brand only has value because of its government protected mail service.  The government backing and guaranteed foot traffic makes it easier for Australia Post to make this move.

There is no point in complaining about this to the regulators, they will look into it and say that Australia Post is acting within the Act.  I have been down that road before.  This is a political problem which requires a political solution.  What we need is politicians who care about business and, in paticular, small business.

Where will one of these Australia Post ATMs appear next?  I will be interested to see how far this network grows.

I am grateful to a reader of this blog for the tip and photo.

0 likes
Australia Post

Australia Post stands firm on magazine delivery price hike

B&T is reporting this afternoon that Australia Post is standing firm on its price increase (3.6% for magazines) despite publisher and printer representations yesterday.  magazine publishers ought to engage with newsagents on a hybrid model which does not use Australia Post.  Make newsagencies the collection point.  The consumer saves on the cover price and we benefit from the traffic.  While this will not suit every subscriber, it would be worth running a pilot.

While I mentioned this a couple of days ago, here is more information on how this could work:

  • Publishers send newsagents subscription copies of magazines for collection by customers.  These are sent with existing magazine deliveries.
  • Subscription copies are labelled with customer details and placed securely with other putaways.
  • The customer is advised by text message that the subscription is ready to be collected once it arrives in-store.
  • When a customer collects their subscription, this is scanned and the publisher advised that collection has been successful.
  • At any point in time the publisher or the newsagent could see what is yet to be collected.
  • Newsagents offer to extend the subsccription as it nears its end, take payment and provide details to the publisher – to their standards.
  • Newsagents offer to sell subscriptions to new customers for this service for an agreed fee of the annual subscription.

I’d see a collect subscription costing more because of the additional services provided.

Australia Post has a monopoly.  3.6% this year, who knows what next year.   Publishers and newsagents working together could come up with a solution which benefits both sides.  However, for it to work, there needs to be no middleman between publishers and newsagents taking a clip.

0 likes
Australia Post

Australia Post set to launch magazine

aust_today_post.JPGAustralia Today is a new magazine being launched by Australia Post on June 29.  Priced at $3.50 per issue, the first issue will be free from Australia Post outlets.  Judging by the cover, Australia Today will have broad appeal: entertainment, food, lifestyle and travel.

This is an interesting move on a range of fronts including: magazines getting into Australia Post and the Government owned business pulling advertiser dollars from current magazines.

No matter how you view the launch, it is a disruptive move by this government owned operation.  It is another example of Australia Post using the protection of their monopoly to take revenue from other businesses.

Newsagents wanting to read advertising for Australia Today should turn to the back page of TV Week.

0 likes
Australia Post

Australia post price rise hits publishers

Mediaweek yesterday published a report about the impact of Australia Post price rises on magazine publishers and subscriptions fulfilled through Australia Post.

Publishers have been reacting angrily to notification from Australia Post this week about price increases which will affect the cost of filling subscriptions. One of Australia’s largest subscription fulfillment houses, D&D Mailing Services, has circulated a letter from director David Docherty it sent to Australia Post. One of D&D’s customers has subsequently forwarded it to Mediaweek. It reads in part:

This Increase is 3.9% for Parcels, 3.6% for PrintPost and a further increase to Line haul rates of 3.1% which ultimately increases PrintPost to a weighted average increase of 4.6% in most cases.

I received notice of these increases in my Sydney office from Australia Post dated 1 June 2009. The notice indicates that the increases are effective from Monday 6 July 2009 (1 months notice).

This increase is only 9 months from the last increase. Therefore the increase at this time (3 months earlier) means a further 33% increase to Australia Post profits and an unbudgeted and unplanned impost to customers as it hits one financial quarter earlier than previous years which effectively has an underlying annual increase of a further 1% increase than advised.

This is from the same Australia Post which aggressively targets small business newsagencies with its 865 government owned corporate stores.

The federal government needs to rein in this business it wholly owns.

In the meantime, newsagents ought to work closely with publishers on selling a new type of subscription – a customer pick up.  Lock in the traffic and have an opportunity to sell a year of copies and get the money, albeit a smaller amount, up front.  I know there are some challenges in this proposal, at least we ought to be at the table discussing them.  The Australia Post price rise presents an opportunity to do this.

0 likes
Australia Post

The Australia Post gift shop

auspost_mothers.JPGThe bear and other items on display in the Government owned Australia Post shop say nothing about postage, the core product of this business. Not content to pursue independent newsagents through their stationery and greeting card offers, this Government owned business is also pursuing traditional seasons such as Mother’s day by offering items you would usually expect to find in a newsagency at this time.

One way the Prime Minister could help small business newsagents would be to turn Government owned Post Offices into, well, Post Offices.

The Act does, after all, say that postal services are the core and the rest are to be incidental. Visit a Government owned Post Office and see how they treat these incidental items compared to their core products.

0 likes
Australia Post

Financial crisis hits US Postal Service

The head of the U.S. Postal Service went before Congress late last week to deliver a submission seeking help in the wake of a considerable downturn in business.  While there are considerable differences between the US Postal Service and Australia Post, reading the report led me to wonder about the health of our mail delivery sevice and whether Australia Post will further increase focus on non mail delivery service revenue streams.

0 likes
Australia Post

Australia Post lets fellow tenants down

auspost_fh_satclose.JPGThe government owned Australia Post shop opposite our newsXpress Forest Hill store has changed its hours on a Saturday.  It now closes at 1pm.  Tenants in a shopping centre have an obligation to support each other.  We rely on the traffic Australia Post pulls as do other retailers nearby – indeed we rely on each other.  It is the government ownership of Australia Post which allows them to get away with this arrogant behaviour.

0 likes
Australia Post

New look Australia Post retail

newlookaussie.JPGThe Government owned Australia Post outlet opposite my Forest Hill store has undergone considerable change over the last two weeks – more than just the card changed I blogged about recently.  The new look is more open and welcoming – except when the custtomer line snakes through the store.  Looking in Friday morning, it certainly looks more welcoming than before – much less like a post office.  I will be interested to see other changes they bring to this government-owned retail model.

0 likes
Australia Post

Is Australia Post changing its card strategy?

ap_cards.JPGI noticed an Australia Post outlet promoting 50% off greeting cards on the weekend. I saw another with the same offer today. Then I saw the Government owned Australia Post outlet with all cards removed from their fixturing – as shown in the photo. I wonder if Australia Post is changing its greeting card strategy. I know that cards have been underperforming for years in the Government owned outlets, certainly not achieving the ROI or return on floor space desired by the managers of the 865 strong Government owned retail chain.

The 50% off promotion is odd. It is running for two weeks but it excludes key seasonal offers such as Easter cards. While I would expect their supplier to be funding the offer, it is unfortunate that this Government owned business is again chasing business from independent small retailers like newsagencies.

0 likes
Australia Post

Officeworks sells stamps now

officeworks_stamps.JPGI was surprised to see stamps advertised as being available at Officeworks. When we applied for one of our newsagencies Australia Post refused. They said we were too close to one of their shops. I know of an Officeworks next to an Australia Post shop. I bet they have stamps. It is wrong for Australia Post to do a deal with Officeworks yet refuse an individual newsagent for being too close.

That said, I am not surprised as I expect the two businesses have ties elsewhere which were leveraged to make this deal happen.

3 likes
Australia Post

How the Federal Government hurts small business

fhn_apost_dec08.JPGThrough more than 850 Federal Government owned and operated retail Post Offices the government’s commitment to a sustainable small business economy is mocked. Successive Federal Governments have sat on their hands and allowed the bosses at Australia Post stray further beyond offering the services permitted under the Act. Indeed, they had the Act drafted in such a way as to make it hard to prosecute a case against Australia Post for selling books, CDs, DVDs, general stationery, ink, cameras, BBQ sets – all manner of items already available from thousands of stores across Australia.

The Australia Post Christmas catalogue is a perfect example of how Government ownership is being abused.

Australia Post, thanks to its monopoly protection around postal services, lands people in its shops for a fraction of what a newsagent costs. A look inside the door of a Government owned outlet shows this stamp and service business looking more and more like a newsagency and other retail outlets. I took the photo of the entrance to the Government owned outlet at Forest Hill (VIC) earlier this week.

I don’t blame Australia Post. They have successfully manipulated the process to get politicians and policy on their side.

The politicians have been convinced into thinking that Australia Post needed these other products to make their retail network viable. This is what the former Minister responsible, Senator Helen Coonan, told me when I met to discuss this issue (without success).

If the current Federal Government is serious about small business it will research how the retail Post network operates overseas and research the impact of Australia Post’s retail expansion has hurt businesses like newsagencies over the last ten years. Overseas they will see that best practice is considered to be retail outlets that focus on postal services. Back home they will find that small business retailers like newsagents have lost, I’d estimate, more than $100 million to the Government retail network.

The Howard Government failed to engage on this issue for its entire tenure. This is an opportunity for the Rudd Government to show if they are serious about small business.

0 likes
Australia Post

Australia Post discounts Christmas cards

apcarddisc.JPGI was surprised to see this sign outside the Government owned Australia Post store at Forest Hill yesterday. Not only is Australia Post pushing deeper into traditional newsagency lines but they are discounting Christmas cards at a time when there should be no discount. I suspect that the supplier of greeting cards is funding this. Australia Post would have relied on their network size, established by virtue of their Government monopoly and protection, to negotiate the deal.

Card experts tell me that Australia Post does not do that well with greeting cards. Maybe so. however, the category is there in Post Shops, at the front and making their businesses look like newsagencies.

I wish that Post Offices were Post Offices as they are in many other countries and that the Government retail network of 860 or so stores stopped trying to take customers from newsagencies like mine. They abuse their government ownership to their competitive advantage. Rather than offering an incidental service as the Act under which they operate states, they aggressively pursue their small bus8iness competitors.

0 likes
Australia Post

Australia Post mocks competition policy

postoffice_nov08.JPGToday is a perfect example of why the Federal Government should not own and operate the retail network of Australia Post shops. By closing Australia Post shops in Victoria today and avoiding penalty rates, the Government demonstrates, again, the advantage they have over newsagents.

While Government owned Post Offices are closed, newsagents in shopping centres are forced to remain open.

From around 2pm today, shopping malls across Victoria will be empty – the Melbourne Cup is the race that stops the nation after all.

While retailers around them will have received a letter, call and or fax from their landlord demanding that they are open for the entire hours which the centre is open, Australia Post can make their own rules. Their excuse is that they are a Government service.

Australia Post shops are more newsagency than Post Office. The government service side of the business is the lure to get people to their stores. More than 80% of their floorspace is used for selling products newsagents and other small independent retailers sell.

Their ability to close today saves a considerable sum of money. I wish I had the same option – not that I would use it. The double standards frustrate me.

I had hoped that the Rudd Labor Government would help small business and fix the abuse of Government ownership by Australia Post.

0 likes
Australia Post

Flexing the monopoly

aposep08.JPGI don’t mind competing with Dick Smith, JB Hi Fi, Harvey Norman, Officeworks or Big W in the ink and toner category. I do mind competing with Australia Post government owned stores. They are trading off a brand which is respected only because of its government ownership and protection. When they advertise great prices, consumers are likely to believe them.  Comparing our prices to these so called great prices from Australia Post, we beat them. But we cannot beat their brand awareness.

This latest campaign by Australia Post is another example of their abuse of the protection their Government ownership affords them.

0 likes
Australia Post

Australia Post expensive for ink

apo_sep08.JPGI should be grumpy at Australia Post continuing to ignore the provisions of the Act under which it operates – the latest catalogue shows the Government owned organisation selling items way outside its charter. What chess sets and BBQ sets have to do with a postal service is beyond me. As I said, I should be grumpy, but I am not. In this catalogue they have a page devoted to ink. All but two of the items they sell are more expensive than our price. This means I can point to the Government owned post office opposite my newsagency at Forest Hill as being expensive and out of touch on price. Even with our lower prices our margins are healthy. Either the Australia Post buyer has not done well or the organisation is too greedy. Either way, they have positioned themselves as expensive when it comes to ink and toner.

0 likes
Australia Post

Australia Post pushing Reflex

apo_reflex.JPGThe buying power of the Government owned Australia Post retail network is in plain view with their current offer of reflex for $4.95 a ream. While Big W and other retailers offer reflex for this price from time to time, only Australia Post pulls consumers in for such a low cost – thanks to their postal products monopoly.

This is where they abuse the protection of Government ownership. The Government owned Post Office opposite my newsagency ought not be competing with me in stationery – a sentiment shared with many newsagents in my situation.

UPDATE: I am reliably informed that Licenced Post Offices buy Reflex for $4.82 including GST.  Not happy I suspect.

0 likes
Australia Post

Trading Post smacks newsagents

Decades of faithful support from newsagents of the Trading Post weekly newspaper has been “rewarded” by the publisher choosing Australia Post as the partner for its expanded online Trading Post auction offering. Traders will need to go to an Australia Post outlet (and stand in a line for too long) to complete a 100 point check to be approved by the Trading Post. This is an insult to newsagents who could have easily provided the 100 point check service and another example of the disregard Trading Post publisher Sensis has for our channel.

0 likes
Australia Post

The Vodafone window

voda_apo.JPGThe Government owned Australia Post shop opposite our newsagency had a big display window promoting Vodafone installed late last week.  It looks better in person than the photo shows.  We are jealous of the professional looking window and the deal they must on to justify the space and stock investment.

Mobile phone handsets are a challenge for newsagencies as our stores carry more stock per square metre than most other retailers, space is limited.  Newsagencies are visually noisy too – a corporate display like for Vodafone would get lost when competing with bold magazine displays and lottery jackpot displays.

We have some ideas on how handsets could be represented and this is something we hope to play with soon.

0 likes
Australia Post

Kudos to Australia Post

wd_ap.JPGThe Australia Post ad on the back page of the current issue of Woman’s Day is brilliant.

This is the kind of ad I want to see from my government owned national postal service. It’s promoting the mail service – not stationery or picnic sets or sports memorabilia or calendars or magazines.

This ad gets Australia Post back to its postal service roots. Well done whoever created this campaign!

0 likes
Australia Post

What happened to the postal service?

fiery3149.jpgAustralia Post’s Mothers Day brochure demonstrates how far the government owned retail outlets have strayed from the services they are required to offer under the Act.

There are gift cards, books and all manner of Mother’s Day items but no stamps or postal services.

The Act permits Australia Post to get into other areas if they incidental. This Mother’s day flyer is hardly incidental. They are using the postal service brand to take business from private businesses like newsagencies.

I hope that Stephen Conroy, the new Minister responsible, takes a careful look at Australia Post and best practice in the area of a national postal service.

0 likes
Australia Post

Australia Post expensive for ink

ap_ink.JPGOur newsXpress Hot Ink pricing beats the ink offer being put about by Australia Post government owned stores.

Where we can’t beat the protected Australia Post retail network is in cost of traffic generation. Their monopoly over postal products and the brand recognition and traffic this brings means customer acquisition costs less than in newsagencies. This is what the ACCC should look at when they review cross-subsidisation within Australia Post.

The photo is of a two page flyer Australia Post is distributing at the moment. While the deals are not that great, that they come out under the Australia Post brand will take some ink business from us.

I hope that the new Federal Government engages more on this issue that the previous Government. They need to decide whether it is acceptable that the retail network they own and protect is used to take revenue from independent small businesses.

0 likes
Australia Post

AFL JSquad magazine in Australia Post

aflj.JPG While the JSquad magazine website says it’s available at newsagents and K-Mart, a colleague spotted the magazine in an Australia Post Post Shop last week. Not a newsagency which is also a Licenced Post Office, no, a full on Post Office.

Post Offices don’t sell magazines but not for lack of trying. For years there have been reports of Australia Post pursuing magazine publishers to have their products in Australia Post retail outlets.

Magazines, newspapers and lottery products are the last categories from newsagencies to be targeted by Australia Post.

Australia Post is a government protected monopoly. My view is that through its 865 or so government owned retail stores it has strayed way beyond the brief permitted by the act of parliament under which it operates. If it does bring magazines into its mix it will be time for newsagents to rally to stop Australia Post using its protection to hurt small family businesses.

0 likes
Australia Post

Australia Post milking the monopoly

ap_carpark.JPGThe photo is of a sign outside the government owned Australia Post retail shop at Forest Hill, in front of car park spaces reserved for Australia Post vehicles. To the left of this Australia Post car park is another spot painted in yellow and marked for Australia Post delivery vehicles.

I rarely see any more than one Australia Post vehicle in any of the spots set aside for the Government owned business. Sure, some plain looking cars could be for mail contractors but I suspect not all of them.

The privilege of this car park space right at their front door is another example of special treatment afforded Australia Post because of the monopoly protection it has from the Federal Government. If they want to take retail sales from small business newsagents, as they are doing, they ought to have these car parking and other protected privileges taken away.

0 likes
Australia Post

The Australia Post phone company

ap_phone.JPGThe brochure on the left has been pushed out far and wide by Australia Post. It makes the Post Office look like a phone retailer which they are in some locations. What is it with this government enterprise? Are they not happy with their postal service monopoly to the extent that they have to continue to take on small business. There are franchisees and independent small retailers across the country offering phones and related product. If there was a hole in coverage I’d understand but there isn’t. Australia Post’s government owned stores ought to get back to their roots and stop using their protection to hurt small businesses.

0 likes
Australia Post