A blog on issues affecting Australia's newsagents, media and small business generally. More ...

Author: Mark Fletcher

Seductive benchmarking

Owning two newsagencies (Forest Hill and Frankston) and a shareholding in another (Watergardens) provides me with access to up to the minute intimate data about the businesses. This abundance of data from three different newsagencies is seductive and the learnings considerable.

Take magazines, we can see a category up in one store and flat or down in the others. We dig deeper and find out why and make some changes. Another example is diaries. In two stores we’re seeing excellent sales while the third is yet to get the diary story out. When they saw the data from the other two they actioned it right away.

Being able to easily compare across a common IT platform and using common department and category structure is fantastic.

I can see all three newsagencies significantly benefiting from access to the pool of data – the key is to not be seduced too deeply into analysis.

0 likes
Newsagency challenges

Magazine hot pockets

The magazine hot pockets we’re using at our Watergardens location are working very well. We are using them as part of our co-location strategy – bringing titles from another category into a higher volume area.

wg_hotpocket.JPG

We’re finding that we need to move these titles regularly to get the best return on the space. I can see that as the business grows we will have a weekday offer and a different weekend offer – reflecting the change in demographic over those times.

0 likes
magazines

OzLotto bonus traffic

Based on the sales increase over the last five days, I am hoping the OzLotto jackpots again tonight. Sales data shows that OzLotto has been the best game over the last year at generating additional traffic.

0 likes
Lotteries

How much for a 2006 desk calendar refill?

calendar_refill.JPGA couple of colleagues from Sydney on Saturday commented that our $2.00 price for 2008 desk calendar refills at Forest Hill was high. Their price was around 20% less. I checked our buy price and sure enough we were marking the calendar blocks up higher than usual – because at $2.00 we considered it to be still good value.

The $2.00 price point was considered carefully by Jason, our manager at Forest Hill. He went for a price which he felt was fair for the product and which was convenient – being at the counter, these are an impulse item at this time of the year. His view, with which I agree, is that the extra we make on this item is balanced by the thin margin on paper and some other products.

Given that newsagents are considered expensive by consumers, there is no point in trimming margin for what is to many an essential item. We’d rather leave margin trimming for promotions.

We’ve had the desk calendar refills out for five days and sales are excellent so price does not seem to be a barrier at Forest Hill.

I was in another newsagency yesterday at the same desk calendar refills were priced at $2.85. This is way too high.

I have been thinking a lot about this issue since Saturday. It goes to the heart of how we manage the stationery department in our businesses. Our competitors balance margin in the same way airlines balance ticket prices on a flight. Where they apply research and discipline to the task, we tend to operate off a flat margin with little consideration of what price an item could carry.

I think there is an opportunity for newsagents to talk more, in small groups, about how they approach pricing of stationery. While no one approach is right, I am certain that such discussion could improve the return all participants achieve.

0 likes
Stationery

SA State Government turns back on newsagents

This report in today’s Adelaide Advertiser reports the likely impact on small business newsagents as a result of the decision by the State Government to sell keno in TAB and PubTAB outlets. TAB is SA is part of Unitab – the Tattersalls subsidiary. Newsagents have served Keno players well and have an excellent track record for responsible sale of gambling products. There was no need for this move.

What is it with governments and lottery product? In Victoria the State Government prefers supermarkets over newsagents. In NSW the State Government prefers 7-Eleven over newsagents and now in SA the State Government prefers TAB outlets over newsagents.

0 likes
Lotteries

HP beats other brands

I recently blogged that Canon was outselling other ink brands at our Watergardens store. At Forest Hill, HP is the hero brand – easily outselling all other brands of ink. I am surprised by the difference between the hero brand in each store and the next best performing brand.

My real interest in this analysis is getting the product mix right. Ink, with a shelf life, is a category which needs to be managed carefully. We did this recently when we quick generic product – something which has proven to be right for our business.

0 likes
Stationery

Bitch magazine in Frankston

bitch.JPGI am surprised at the difference in magazines I have found at our new Frankston newsagency which we do not receive at Forest Hill.

Take Bitch magazine. It’s an interesting title, appealing to a narrow demographic. What surprises me is that it’s supplied to Frankston and not Forest Hill. There are other titles like – supplied to one and not the other – which, in my probably ignorant view, defy the demographic.

We are finding comparing the businesses fascinating. I expect it will lead to requests for more titles in one of both stores once we get our collective heads around the differences.

As a magazine lover, it’s wonderful to see new (to me) titles like Bitch.

0 likes
magazines

Pink newspapers

pink_ribbon_age.JPGKudos to the folks at The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald for taking the newspaper pink today in support of breast cancer research. Of all the promotions connected with newspapers and magazines over the years, I’d say that printing a newspaper on pink paper generated the most engagement – and awareness is all about just that.

0 likes
Newspapers

Featuring TV related magazines

tv_shows.JPGWe have created a small display of magazine titles relating to TV shows at one of our register points. It’s working a treat with some of the slower moving titles selling off this stand on impulse.

We run displays like this weekly, featuring different categories and, as the photo shows, titles not usually displayed together but with some connection. We choose the display focus based mainly on team member suggestions.

A key element of the display is the border. It tells our customers what the display is about.

Too many newsagents take the set and forget approach to magazines. My view is that change is critical – hence our focus of time and resources on displays such as this one.

0 likes
magazines

calendarXpress website for newsagents

Last Friday, calendarXpress launched a website promoting its line of calendars and participating newsagents. This is an important online initiative designed to drive traffic to and sales for the newsagents involved. By developing other brands for niche categories in our newsagency businesses we can overcome prejudices and attract those who may not browse a newsagency.

calendarXpress, while created by newsXpress, is open to all newsagents as a means of better managing the calendar range and improving margin.

I am a Director of calendarXpress.

0 likes
Calendars

Culture is a key weapon for newsagents

Archie Norman, the UK supermarket guru who engineered the turnaround of the Asda supermarket chain says a winning culture is critical to success. That makes sense. When you read the article, Culture is key weapon in asile wars by Simon Evans in Friday’s AFR (pg 58) the comment about a winning culture makes even more sense.

Norman’s comment about culture has been on my mind this weekend as I have been thinking about some newsagencies I know of which are struggling. You can find an interesting insight into his approach to the job of supermarket boss here.

we have an extraordinary network across the country yet we do little to truly leverage this for our commercial advantage. While some of us may have strong success focused cultures in our individual businesses, the big challenge we face is developing such a culture nationally and consistently.

Given how our stationery, magazines and even greeting card business has performed in recent years compared to our competitors, we need a turnaround expert like Archie Norman telling us how it is and what we must do if we are to succeed.

0 likes
Newsagency challenges

Special interest magazines beat computer titles

SPECIAL INTEREST.JPGWith sales of special interest titles up by 25% this year compared to 2006 and sales of computer magazines down by the same amount it is no surprise that last week we further reduced space allocated to computer titles and increased space allocated to special interest titles.

Layout is key with special interest titles and this is something we work on at least three times a week – ensuring the have appropriate adjacencies and that the many segments within the overall category can be easily identified by browsers.

One challenge is real-estate. With these special interest titles supplied in small quantities we need to find a way to carry more stock in less space yet to still display the titles appropriately. We are working on that.

We balance our real-estate allocation based on data from our computer system. This includes spotting trends which guide us to be opportunistic.

Note to magazine distributors – this is not a green light to send us more stock, we will let you know if we want that.

0 likes
magazines

Quitting stock

We caused a frenzy unlike anything I have seen before at our new Frankston store on Thursday when we decided to quit manynitems we will not carry in the future. We have making some serious brand based moves and needed to quit masses of cheap non branded product imported from China. This photo is toward the end of the sale when things had calmed a bit.

quay1.JPG

Current research indicates that consumers think newsagencies are expensive places to shop. My view is that we ought to embrace this, or part of it at least, and not fight it by going down the $2 or Reject Shop path. That bottom end of the marketplace is well served and I see no reason to take the newsagency shingle there. Maybe for the odd short term sale but not as a long term ranging option.

0 likes
newsagency marketing

People’s Friend – a honey pot title

peoples_friend.JPGPeople’s Friend is one of our best performing weekly magazines at Forest Hill, selling between 65 and 80 copies a week. I was interested to find it performing as well in our new Frankston location. This provides a demographic insight and helps us translate some magazine layout strategies from Forest hill to Frankston.

One of the issues I have seen newsagents struggle with is demographic differences when they move from one location to another. We are using magazine sales as the guide to differences in these first few weeks as we learn the new Frankston business. Hence our interest in finding People’s Friend performing well in both locations.

On People’s Friend, sales are strong enough for us to use this as a honey pot title – we put other titles which need support around or nearby. This strategy, while labour intensive, works a treat. I see several titles benefiting from being close to People’s Friend.

0 likes
magazines

Wrap display drives sales

wrap_angle.JPG

This is how I’d like to display flat wrapping paper in any newsagency own from now on. Beyond the stunning look, customers love it – the product is easier to browse and easier to return to the fixture. It looks as if it is calling out take me take me. The angles fixture also makes it easier to display two designs in a single tray if you need to. The trays are made to order – so that the product is the hero.

Annualising sales since we first tested this approach seven months ago shows that we should generate close to $20,000 a square metre.

The idea for this display and the very specific measurements came from Ben Kay retail manager within my group.

0 likes
giftwrap

eziPass easier than Dialtime

ep_logos.JPG

The most common feedback we are hearing from newsagents who start using eziPass to sell phone recharge product is that it is easier to use than Dialtime. That and the additional commission they are making on key product.

The eziPass roll out to newsagents is going well. How could it not – it’s free, easy to use, reduces paperwork and comes with an excellent reconciliation statement. Oh, and you;re likely to make more money.

The real benefit is the bringing of the sale of phone vouchers to the point of sale software – this considerably cuts mistakes and helps with in-store traffic management.

we launch the stand alone version next week – it is in QA right now. This is for newsagents not using Tower Systems software.

0 likes
phone recharge

Women’s Health kicks

womens_mens.JPGWomen’s Health, the new magazine launched by Pacific Magazines on Monday this week is kicking some huge goals based on sales data I am seeing. Sell through rates of 50% and above for a launch title not even seven days is fantastic by any measure. I have seen plenty of copies sold at the counter, as an impulse purchase – demonstrating the effectiveness of the Pacific marketing and advertising campaigns.

What is also fascinating is the kick Men’s Health is achieving as a result.

0 likes
magazines

The Form racing insert/newspaper launches in Vic

the_form_vic.JPG

The Age last week rebranded its Friday sports section as The Form. As I have blogged here previously, The Form could be the start of a new free newspaper offering from Fairfax. While it is included in The Age in Melbourne, In Sydney it is a separate free publication with the Sydney Morning Herald and presents distribution challenges for newsagents.

Victorian newsagents ought to talk with their NSW colleagues to understand more the impact of the launch of The Form as separate from the newspaper.

0 likes
Newspapers

The charity christmas card pitch

christmas_cards.JPG

Boxed Christmas cards have changed considerably in Australia over recent years. This year, more than ever, it is a charity story with each of the major publishers embracing charities centrally in their pitch. The charity brand pulls focus from the brand of the product itself.

What was a point of difference for one or two card companies in 2005 is now me too. Card companies will need to find other ways to distinguish their offering since there must be considerable competition for charity endorsement.

In London last November I noticed that every boxed card offering from major publishers had a charity connection. That is true here this year for the first time. While I support the charity contribution, it makes for a noisy marketplace. I wonder if we ought to do more at the retail level to engage beyond selling the product.

0 likes
Greeting Cards

G magazine for the green lifestyle

g.JPGWe received our first issue of G magazine Wednesday. Looking through it, I see an opportunity to create a new display category, bringing together titles around the climate change theme. Some titles such as G and Renew will anchor the category and others, such as this month’s National Geographic will make appearances based on their cover story.

The problem with creating an environmental category is where to put it. Of the six to eight titles I see as fitting in currently, only two are in the same MPA category. We’ll sort it out and have a crack.

I am glad G has been launched – it could help us carve out a new niche.

0 likes
magazines

Lying reps say anything for a sale

A rep visited my Frankston store on Tuesday telling Simon, the manager, that I had asked them to visit to discuss putting their stock into the business. I had made no such request. I am tired of reps turning up without an appointment and lying to get an order. Newsagents deserve better.

0 likes
supplier arrogance

Bookmarks drive magazine sales

ji2.JPG

What did you notice first in this photo of magazines? Hopefully it was the four yellow tags. They are a bright yellow arrow pointing to a title as being just in. These bookmarks are our latest innovation in magazine promotion which we are going to be rolling out exclusively through newsXpress locations.

I have had the idea for some time but creating the high quality form cut bookmarks was too expensive for one store. Rolling it out across 150 stores is more viable. It also provides newsXpress an excellent opportunity to demonstrate again its credentials in innovation in magazine marketing.

ji1.JPG

Vogue Living is a good example where these bright bookmarks can work well. Being monthly it is easy for consumers to forget when the next issue is in – especially if they do not purchase every issue. By being selective in our placement of the bookmarks and limiting the number in use at any time, they become a beacon to eyeballs.

With so much visual noise in a newsagency it is easy for regulars to become store blind. This is a real problem for poster displays. I think a small number of the bright just in bookmarks could do more for the selected titles than a poster display stuck someone on a wall in the newsagency.

ji3.JPG

Slimming and Health is another good example of where our bookmark strategy will work – even if we get two or three extra glances a day that will lead to impulse purchases.

Just as others copied the magazine club card I developed in 2004, I’d expect other marketing groups to copy this innovation. There is more to this than printing a bookmark and sticking it in a few titles. The bookmarks have been painstakingly designed, the colours carefully chosen and the research undertaken on the number to use at any one time and the titles on which to focus.

While publishers focus attention on newsagents who do aisle end and other poster displays, our view, arrogantly, is that innovation like these bookmarks is far more valuable as drive drive systemic change in the management of magazines in newsagencies.

There were skeptics in 2004 when I created the magazine club card – newsagencies which have embraced this are delivering considerably above average magazine growth primarily because of the loyalty offering.

The newsXpress just in bookmarks won’t deliver a retirement size cash bonus but they will help drive above average magazine sales. They provide practical evidence of the newsXpress point of difference and further support our brand over individual product brands.

0 likes
magazines

John Howard’s small business credentials

Take a look at the latest Annual Report from Australia Post and see how successfully this wholly government owned and government protected enterprise has leveraged its monopoly brand even more successfully this year to take revenue from Australia’s family owned newsagencies. Mr Howard and his team have permitted and even encouraged the 846 Australia Post corporate stores to go after newsagencies in the areas of stationery, bill payment, phone recharge and other areas. They hide behind the legislation and conveniently forget that they can change this. yes, they care about small business.

0 likes
Australia Post

The Cult Times copy

cult_times.JPGCult Times magazine and the TV Zone Inter Special title (right) are the same – certainly a read of the text of the cover suggests as much as does the photo. To really check I’d need to open the sealed bag of the title on the right. Customers won’t notice. The bagged magazine is more expensive.

They appeal to the same demographic so why duplicate copy and put it under a different masthead? Unless there is substantial difference in content this repackaging ought not be permitted as unsuspecting consumers could be ripped off. My benchmark would be that a title would need to have at least 50% unpublished content. I suspect that is not the case with Cult Times and its sister publication.

I am annoyed because customers who been ripped off will complain to us as the retailer.

0 likes
magazines