A blog on issues affecting Australia's newsagents, media and small business generally. More ...

Author: Mark Fletcher

Off the record, off the blog

I don’t want to read this on the blog … This is for you and not for the blog … Just don’t blog about it … Off the record means off the blog.

These are just some of the statements which have preceeded meetings I take and phonecalls I receive since this blog really started attracting traffic (currently an average of 1,450 visits a day).  Some people think that I blog anything I hear or am told.  I don’t.  These people don’t know me that well.  Early in my blogging I found the Bloggers Code of Ethics at CyberJournalist and have tried to blog to those standards since.

I am told many things by newsagents, suppliers and others connected with the channel.  I have a good sense of when someone tells me something hoping it will lead to a blog post.  I tend to ignore these situations unless I think it would be genuinely inetresting or useful.

0 likes
Blogging

The magazine relay

I and some colleagues are doing a magazine relay today (when I land back in Melbourne from Sydney) for a newsagent, to reinvent their magazine offer.  We have been planning the relay for a week (off and on), considering sales data, demographics, the MPA magazine layout recommendations and gut feel.

As should happen with magazine relays, we are going into this with the view that what we do today is not a destination – no magazine re-location should be considered to be this.  Indeed, it is about change, change and more change.  This keeps the offer fresh and ensures it continues to improve.

The layout of magazines needs to be assessed in each newsagency at least annually.  By assessed, I mean reviewed physically and through magazine performance reports.  The category responds well to change – there is commercial value in playing with the layout based on what customers are buying and looking for.

0 likes
magazines

NSW/ACT Newsagent of the Year Awards

dsc06673.JPGCongratulations to NANA for a good night last night at their Newsagent of the Year Awards.

Congratulations and kudos too to the stars of the evening – Van Nguyen Tuan Tra of Wincamden Newsagency for winning the Distribution Newsagent of the Year Award and Allen and Brenda Kavanagh of Greenhills Newsagency for winning Retail Newsagent of the Year award.

More than 160 people attended the event – a show of tremendous support for the work of NANA.

The photo shows the businesses which financially supported the Awards dinner.  This includes my own Tower Systems.  I mention the sponsors because the suppliers supporting newsagent events demonstrate, financially, their commitment to the channel – support them.

0 likes
Newsagency opportunities

Damaged chocolate devalues the magazine

fhn_nathealth_choc2.JPGThe value of the free block of chocolate bagged with the latest issue of Australian Natural Health which came out yesterday has not survived the distribution process well. The packaging of every block Scraborough Fair organic blameless chocolate in my shop looks damaged. These giveaways are only valuable if they look good to the consumer in-store.  We considered featuring this title but could not find any worthy of the prime space.

0 likes
magazine distribution

The fat Silicon Chip magazine

fhn_silchip.JPGSilicon Chip magazine this month comes with an advertising catalogue which is four times the thickness of the magazine itself.  This creates a retail space challenge for newsagents without any financial benefit.

At the very least the publisher should pay newsagents for the addditional space required to handle this fat magazine package.

0 likes
magazines

Bonus margin for Popular Science

fhn_popsci_apr09.JPGWe are chasing the bonus margin on this month’s Popular Science by promoting it in its usual place – men’s lifestyle – as well as next to our main newspaper stand.  If we achieve a greater than 50% sell-through, our margin for Popular Science goes from 25% to 35%.  extra margin focuses the mind of retailers.  If only this was a long term arrangement – reward for additional effort would see newsagents act more proactively for the titles involved.

0 likes
magazines

Promoting Good Taste at the counter

fhn_goodtaste.JPGWe are promoting the Woolworths branded Good Taste magazine at our prime counter position for the next few days because of the free magnetic shopping list which comes with the title. Our feeling is that Good Taste will sell well from this location – hence the display between our two busiest registers and the call to action on the pad – Buy Me!

With a title like Good Taste being promoted heavily elsewhere, it makes sense for us to try and sell out early in the cycle.

0 likes
magazines

Lack of collateral to support Women’s Weekly

fhn_aww.JPGThe latest issue of the Australian Women’s Weekly went on sale today and while we received stock, we received one folded poster to support the title.  The Souvenir Edition will appeal to our customers so we have created a cover based display at the front of the shop. This would have looked so much better had we received professional marketing collateral commensurate with the status of this issue.

0 likes
magazines

New XchangeIT pricing

The new annual access pricing announced by XchangeIT, the company owned by the three magazine distributors and through which newsagents receive electronic invoice data and provide sales data, at the QNF conference yesterday of $695 for users of the POS Solutions DOS software, $895 for non compliant newsagents and $495 for compliant newsagents is a step in the right direction but not far enough if they want to drive compliance among newsagents. Access for compliant newsagents should be free or, at least, token in cost. Only this will focus the minds of newsagents on the value of compliance.  It is important to demonstrate the value to the channel of the many newsagents committed to efficiency and the cost of those who are not.

0 likes
Newsagency challenges

Suppliers supporting newsagents

Here are the suppliers who funded the QNF Queensland Newsagent State Conference the event yesterday.

supportingnewsagents.jpg
As one who regularly supports such events through newsXpress and Tower Systems, it is frustrating that it is the same suppliers who stump up cash for newsagent conferences, golf days and the like. The best way newsagents can encourage more suppliers to open their wallets is to support the suppliers who fund industry events.

0 likes
Newsagency opportunities

Meeting Queensland newsagents

dsc06648.JPGI am grateful to have had an opportunity to speak at the QNF Queensland Newsagents State Conference today. I spoke on Living with Google – how we need to operate our newsagencies in this Google dominated world where the traditional business rules have been abandoned and our core products are challenged. I see our response to the changed world in simple terms:

  • Take responsibility. We need to be responsible for our businesses. This means NOT relying on suppliers or others to lead us. We have to lead ourselves – individually and collectively as appropriate to our circumstances. Too many newsagents have bought into the channel in pursuit of an income. Those who have bought in to own and operate a business will fare better.
  • Stand for something. Most newsagents stand for vague points of difference – customer service, being local etc. Each of us needs to stand for something of value, something which defines every decision we make.
  • Take control of our retail space. We need to reject supplier control of our space – unless they pay the rent.
  • Take control of our product mix. We need to control what we sell – suppliers cannot do this for us.
  • Take control of our message. We need to be clear in our message and it needs to reflect what we stand for.
  • It all comes down to change. Our business model is based on old products and old business principles. While the old products will serve us well for some time, we need to transparently and urgently start to change. We should do this in beta – trial and error – and in consultation with our customers. Our customers will be more useful in guiding our future than our existing suppliers.

I met several people at the QNF Conference who are excited to be pushing the boundaries of their newsagencies. They have every right to be excited.
The biggest challenge we have as a channel is the gap emerging between the newsagents changing their businesses and those who do not understand that change is essential.

0 likes
Newsagency opportunities

New fixturing successfully promotes cards

dsc06500.JPGWe are getting good comments from customers shopping the new speciality card fixturing at our Sophie Randall shop at Toorak.  Click on the image for a larger copy.  We continue to play with product location within the fixturing – constant change works well for sales because of the regular customers who love cards.  I’d note this is our feature wall – separate from our everyday  and lifestyle cards.

0 likes
Greeting Cards

Optimistically embracing the global economic crisis

I have been contemplating the future of newsagencies in the context of the GEC (Global Economic Crisis) ahead of my speech today to the Queensland Newsagents State Conference. I’ve been reading plenty about the GEC and the likely impact on businesses like ours, about how retailers traded through the Great Depression and other tough economic cycles.

I am optimistic. If we are smart, newsagents have a bright future. The GEC is an opportunity for us, an opportunity to celebrate being small, local (Australian) and flexible.

  • Being small. Smart newsagents will exploit the opportunity by making quick decisions big businesses are slow (too big) to make. Decisions like changing range, price and positioning.
  • Being local. Smart newsagents will promote their Australianness and the convenience of their location – and do so in the wake of non-locally connected bigger retailers. Newsagencies are in every town yet we do not promote that our excellent geographic positioning saves fuel and time through convenient shopping.
  • Being flexible. Smart newsagents will take their businesses from being newsagencies to being – convenience stores, gift shops, stationery retailers, cafes. They will play with the model in pursuit of what is right for their local situation.  Most of all, they will reduce the space allocation for products over which they have no control.

Of course, if we do nothing then we become spectators of the passing opportunity.

We will get more from our businesses if we engage and participate in the GEC.

0 likes
Newsagency opportunities

Stationery planagrams sell

planogram_sells.JPGWe are seeing excellent results from each part of our stationery department which has been planagrammed.  Among the best results are those we are achieving around the 3M brands.  Not only does the display look stunning, it is appreciated by our customers – as reflected in sales.  Planagrams are easy to implement and can be done without outside involvement: block vertically, by brand within category.  The goal is to make a bold visual statement and it make shopping easier.

0 likes
retail

Goop with the magazines

kzone_goop.JPGThere are some things which should never be distributed with magaiznes – like the tub of green goop with K-Zone magazine which arrived this morning.  While the goop, which looks like alien droppings, lifts off, it is an early morning challenge we’d have been better off without.

0 likes
magazines

Losing trust in newspapers

The shame News Limited newspapers brought upon themselves this past week over the Pauline Hanson nude photos not only reflects poorly on their mastheads but on all newspapers.

Consumers rely on newspapers to check the facts.  Newspapers, in criticising new news mediums such as blogs and social media websites, say it is only their rescources which can produce news which consumers can trust.

In publishing the photos last week and spinning the story for seven days, News Limited showed how poor they can be at the job which they say is the point of difference of their medium.

Nude photos of Pauline Hanson taken by a boyfriend decades ago should never have been considered news.  That they were fake demonstrates how far the publisher has strayed from their mission.

0 likes
Newspapers

Easter plush delivering excellent sales

fhn_easter_plush2.jpgThe table of Easter plush and related gift items we have located in our card department, at the front of the shop, is achieving excellent results.  Each week is better than the last. Since we do not have a defined gift department as such at our Forest Hill store it is a challenge for us to step in and out of the gift space each season.  The changes made by our team for Easter this year- better location, more integrated with cards and Easter eggs, broader range – are working very well for us.  We restock the table daily.

This is a good news business story which has been simple to make happen.   With greeting cards as our anchor for the seasons, it is easy for newsagents to make Easter and other key seasons count for more than just Mother’s Day. We know our Easter sales from last year and have passing them easily as a goal for this year.

The key in today’s climate, from successful newsagents I talk with, appears to be the decision to do more: more than just cards and eggs for a Easter, more than average gifts for Mother’s Day, more than an average magazine display, more than sales only when everyone else has them, more than being an average newsagent.

0 likes
Gifts

Clay Shirky and the future of newspapers

There is a fascinating conversation going on at Clay Shirky’s blog about challenges around newspapers.  It is not a conversation for the feint-hearted.  Clay takes a pragmatic view and rejects the usual reasons we are told that all will be well which newspapers and that we should continue to focus our attention supporting them in our newsagencies.

We need to debate these issues for it is only through this that we, newsagents, can work towards our future.

0 likes
Media disruption

Magazine supply needs urgent adjustment

Magazine sales are down across the newsagency channel since the start of the year yet magazine distributors are yet to adjust supply except for major publisher titles with tightly managed print runs.  Given that we are twelve weeks into 2009, I would have thought that the distributors would have had sufficient sales data with which to adjust allocations.

My concern is for titles outside the top 200, titles which, in most newsagencies, are borderline profitable.  With magazine sales down in newsagencies, on average 12%, magazine distributors ought to be cutting supply and therefore not expecting newsagents to act as their bank until the economy (and magazine sales) improve.

While distributors will argue that they do adjust to reported sales volume, I am only seeing this with titles from ACP Magazines, Pacific Magazines and one or two other publishers.  Supply for the majority of titles has not been adjusted to reflect sales data.  While I am sure there are instances where adjustments are done to reflect slower sales,this is not widespread.

I’d like to see the major publishers engage with the distributors on this issue.  Supply at the current level starves newsagents of cash and this challenges their ability to professionally serve the needs of the top selling titles.  The major publishers could use their economic muscle to help newsagents and help themselves.

Through the work I do with the Tower Newsagent community I see data from many newsagencies each week – I know what I am talking about when it comes to current sales data and the worsening, by inaction on sales data, supply situation for many magazines.  I’d be happy to work with suppliers and provide evidence to support my claims.

Newsagents can easily see the situation for themselves by printing a Magazine Sell Through Rates report.  This will show the fall in performance – due to supply at 2008 levels – for many titles.

The magazine distributors can fix this situation easily by not using newsagents as their bank – by adjusting to reflect current sales data.

This is on my mind this morning because of another email from a newsagent in trouble. They are losing money on magazines and the main distributor at fault is making it hard for them to adjust supply.

0 likes
magazine distribution

New look Australia Post retail

newlookaussie.JPGThe Government owned Australia Post outlet opposite my Forest Hill store has undergone considerable change over the last two weeks – more than just the card changed I blogged about recently.  The new look is more open and welcoming – except when the custtomer line snakes through the store.  Looking in Friday morning, it certainly looks more welcoming than before – much less like a post office.  I will be interested to see other changes they bring to this government-owned retail model.

0 likes
Australia Post